Ten outbreaks of poliomyelitis caused by pathogenic circulating vaccine-derived polioviruses (cVDPVs) have recently been reported in different regions of the world. Two of these outbreaks occurred in Madagascar. Most cVDPVs were recombinants of mutated poliovaccine strains and other unidentified enteroviruses of species C. We previously reported that a type 2 cVDPV isolated during an outbreak in Madagascar was co-circulating with coxsackieviruses A17 (CA17) and that sequences in the 3′ half of the cVDPV and CA17 genomes were related. The goal of this study was to investigate whether these CA17 isolates can act as recombination partners of poliovirus and subsequently to evaluate the major effects of recombination events on the phenotype of the recombinants. We first cloned the infectious cDNA of a Madagascar CA17 isolate. We then generated recombinant constructs combining the genetic material of this CA17 isolate with that of the type 2 vaccine strain and that of the type 2 cVDPV. Our results showed that poliovirus/CA17 recombinants are viable. The recombinant in which the 3′ half of the vaccine strain genome had been replaced by that of the CA17 genome yielded larger plaques and was less temperature sensitive than its parental strains. The virus in which the 3′ portion of the cVDPV genome was replaced by the 3′ half of the CA17 genome was almost as neurovirulent as the cVDPV in transgenic mice expressing the poliovirus cellular receptor gene. The co-circulation in children and genetic recombination of viruses, differing in their pathogenicity for humans and in certain other biological properties such as receptor usage, can lead to the generation of pathogenic recombinants, thus constituting an interesting model of viral evolution and emergence.
Following intense vaccination campaigns with Sabin's trivalent live-attenuated oral poliovirus vaccine, poliomyelitis caused by wild polioviruses has disappeared from large parts of the world. However, poliomyelitis outbreaks due to pathogenic circulating vaccine-derived polioviruses (cVDPVs) have recently been reported in countries with low vaccine coverage. Most of these cVDPVs seem to be recombinants of mutated vaccine strains and undetermined coxsackieviruses. We have previously shown a cVDPV isolated during an outbreak in Madagascar to be co-circulating with coxsackievirus A17 (CA17) strains with 3′ genomic sequences related to those of the cVDPV. In this study, we determined whether these CA17 isolates can act as recombination partners of poliovirus. Using genetic engineering techniques, we constructed a variety of recombinant viruses derived from a CA17 isolate, the cVDPV and the corresponding original vaccine strain. Our results showed that poliovirus/CA17 recombinants are viable. Moreover, the recombinant virus resulting from the replacement of the 3′ half of the cVDPV genome by that of the CA17 genome was almost as pathogenic as the cVDPV. This supports the notion that co-circulation and co-evolution through the recombination of polioviruses and coxsackieviruses contribute to the emergence of epidemic cVDPVs. This constitutes an interesting model of viral evolution and emergence.
Citation: Jegouic S, Joffret M-L, Blanchard C, Riquet FB, Perret C, et al. (2009) Recombination between Polioviruses and Co-Circulating Coxsackie A Viruses: Role in the Emergence of Pathogenic Vaccine-Derived Polioviruses. PLoS Pathog 5(5): e1000412. doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412
Editor: Esteban Domingo, Centro de Biología Molecular Severo Ochoa (CSIC-UAM), Spain
Received: December 31, 2008; Accepted: April 6, 2009; Published: May 1, 2009
Copyright: © 2009 Jegouic et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was partly supported by grants from the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs (FSP 2001-168), the Direction of International Affairs of the Institut Pasteur (ACIP A/22/06), and the Transverse Research Programs of the Institut Pasteur (PTR276). Sophie Jegouic is granted by the French Delegation Generale pour l'Armement (DGA) and the French Centre National pour la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The Sabin's trivalent live-attenuated oral poliovirus vaccine (OPV) includes viral strains of three serotypes (Sabin 1, 2 and 3). These strains replicate in the digest tract following vaccination, inducing a strong local intestinal immune response that limits subsequent poliovirus (PV) replication and viral transmission in humans . OPV is the main tool used in the Poliomyelitis Eradication Initiative, which was launched by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 1988 to eradicate this acute paralytic disease (http://www.polioeradication.org/). Following intense vaccination campaigns, wild polioviruses have disappeared from major parts of the world, remaining endemic in only four countries, India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Nigeria . Nevertheless, low vaccine coverage over recent years has allowed occasional spread of wild PV strains from endemic countries to neighboring or distant countries where wild PV had disappeared . Moreover, low vaccine coverage can lead to transmission of OPV strains to non-immunized people, allowing genetic drift and subsequent loss of their attenuation characteristics ,. Ten outbreaks due to pathogenic circulating vaccine-derived polioviruses (cVDPVs) have recently been reported, two of which occurred in Madagascar in 2001–2002 and 2005 , –.
All but one of the cVDPV outbreaks were due to recombinant lineages between vaccine PVs and other unidentified human enteroviruses of species C (HEV-C) , –. HEV-C (Picornaviridae family) include PVs and related coxsackie A virus serotypes – (http://www.ictvonline.org/). Enteroviruses are non-enveloped viruses with a single positive-strand RNA genome approximately 7.5 kb long. The single large coding region of the genome is flanked by 5′ and 3′-untranslated regions (5′- and 3′UTR). The coding region is translated as a single polyprotein, which is then processed by viral proteases to yield mature viral proteins including the capsid proteins (VP1 to VP4) and non-structural proteins . In recombinant cVDPV genomes, large parts of the region encoding non-structural proteins, the 3′UTR and in some cases the 5′UTR are derived from non-poliovaccine HEV-C –,,.
Recombination in enteroviruses was discovered in 1962 ,. The ability of enteroviruses to undergo extensive recombination is now well established, and represents another mechanism, together with mutations, by which these viruses generate diversity and evolve –. Recombination is also thought to be involved in repair of deleterious mutations in genomes ,. However, the role of recombination in the generation and function of recombinant strains — in particular of the newly discovered recombinant cVDPVs — remains unclear ,,.
During the polio-outbreak in 2001–2002 in Madagascar, two different type 2 recombinant cVDPV lineages, with sequences derived from the 5′ half of the Sabin 2 genome and the 3′ half of non-PV HEV-C, were isolated. ,. Recombination sites were located in the region encoding viral protease 2A. Moreover, many coxsackie A serotypes showing substantial genetic diversity were found in the stools of children living in the small area where most of the poliomyelitis cases occurred . Partial genomic sequencing showed that the sequences of several serotype 17 and 13 coxsackie A viruses (CA17 and CA13) encoding viral proteins 2C and 3Dpol (polymerase), respectively, were closely related to those of the cVDPV sequences. These results suggest that ancestors of these CA17 and CA13 strains were the donors of the HEV-C sequences present in the Madagascar cVDPVs; however, the nucleotide (nt) sequences showing the highest similarity between these coxsackie A viruses and cVDPVs remained significantly different (6–8%). Although these cVDPVs and coxsackie A viruses appear to have common ancestors, the observed differences in nt sequence could have been generated either before or after the recombination event. Finally, other coxsackie A viral strains or serotypes with sequences more closely-related to those of the cVDPVs may have acted as parental donors.
The infectious cDNA of one Madagascar cVDPV (MAD04) belonging to the major lineage isolated in 2002 was cloned and used with that of the original Sabin 2 vaccine strain to construct cDNA-derived recombinants . The results demonstrated that the HEV-C sequences affected the characteristics of this cVDPV. In particular, although the key neurovirulence determinants of MAD04 are located in the 5′ half of the genome (mutated Sabin 2 sequences), the HEV-C-derived 3′ half of the genome affected pathogenicity. However, it is not known whether this effect was due to the primary recombination event involved in the generation of the cVDPV or to subsequent mutations optimizing the functional interactions between both halves of the genome.
We determined whether CA17 strains can be recombination partners of PV and evaluated the key effects of such a recombination event on the phenotype of the recombinants. We cloned the infectious cDNA of a CA17 isolate and used it in conjunction with that of Sabin 2 and MAD04 to construct and characterize chimeric viruses. We found that non-polio HEV-C sequences present in MAD04 can be replaced by CA17 sequences, and that CA17 sequences contribute to the phenotypic characteristics of PV/CA17 recombinants, including pathogenicity.
Genomic sequencing and characterization of the Madagascar CA17.67591 strain
To confirm the relationship between CA17 isolates and the cVDPV MAD04 lineage, we sequenced the whole genome of one of the CA17 isolates (CA17.67591) that was found co-circulating with MAD04  – EMBL Genbank accession number FM955278. The genome of this isolate is 7457 nt long, excluding the poly(A) tail. The CA17.67591 genome encodes a single open-reading frame (encoding a 2213 amino-acid polyprotein) flanked by a 747 nt 5′UTR and a 71 nt 3′UTR.
The nt sequences encoding the VP1 capsid protein of enterovirus isolates are serotype-specific . In an alignment of VP1 nt sequences of CA17.67591 with those of HEV-C prototype strains, the CA17-G12 prototype strain showed the highest nt identity (78%). Alignment of the CA17.67591 VP1 polypeptide also showed high sequence similarity with the VP1 polypeptide of this prototype strain (94%). VP1-encoding genomic regions of both CA17 strains were 918 nt long and differed from those of the other prototype HEV-C strains. Given that enteroviruses of the same serotype generally have >75% nt sequence identity and >85% amino-acid similarity in VP1 regions, these results strongly suggest that the CA17.67591 strain belongs to the same serotype as the prototype strain CA17-G12 –. These results were confirmed by aligning and comparing P1 genomic region nucleotide sequences encoding the capsid proteins of CA17.67591 and of various HEV-C prototypes in phylogenetic trees (maximum likelihood method) (Fig. 1). P1 sequences from CA17.67591 clustered with those of CA17-G12 with high reliability values (percent puzzle steps ≥90%). Similar results were obtained using VP1 nucleotide sequences (not shown). The stem-loop structure containing the AAACA conserved motif, constituting the cis-acting replication element cre(2C), was found in CA17.67591 at nt positions 4461–4521 –.
Figure 1. Phylogenetic tree depicting genetic relationships between nucleotide sequences of CA17.67591, cVDPVs and other HEV-C prototypes.
This neighbor-joining tree was based on nucleotide sequences alignment of genomic regions P1, which encode viral capsid proteins. Branch lengths were calculated using PUZZLE and the Hasegawa, Kishino and Yano (HKY) model of substitution. The genetic distance is indicated (bar). Numbers at nodes correspond to the percentage of 10,000 puzzle steps supporting the distal cluster. Nucleotide sequences of enterovirus 70 (EV70) were used as an outgroup.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.g001
Several non-PV HEV-C (CA13, CA15, CA20 and CA21) bind intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1), which thus acts as a viral cellular receptor (or at least a co-receptor); in most cases, the binding of these strains to cells can be blocked by anti-ICAM-1 antibodies ,,. The CA17 receptor is currently unknown. We therefore tested whether CA17 infection was mediated by ICAM-1, using the prototype CA17-G12 and the isolate CA17.67591. Infection of HEp-2c cells by these two CA17 strains was completely inhibited by the anti-ICAM-1 mAb 8.4 A6 , but not by the anti-CD155 mAb 404  directed against the PV receptor (data not shown). Conversely, HEp-2c cells were completely protected from Sabin 2 infection by the anti-CD155 mAb, but not by the anti-ICAM-1 mAb. These results suggested that infection by CA17-G12 or CA17-67591 is mediated by ICAM-1, as observed for the other non-PV HEV-C.
Comparative analysis of CA17.67591 and cVDPV sequences from Madagascar
We carried out an overall comparative analysis of the genomic nt sequences of the two Madagascar cVDPV lineages (MAD04 and MAD29), Sabin 2 and the prototype strains CA17-G12 and CA13 Flores, by alignment with CA17.67591 nt sequences. Pairwise comparisons were performed using similarity scanning analysis  (Fig. 2A). The highest similarity score was obtained for comparison of the 5′ half of the CA17-G12 sequence (5′UTR and capsid region) with the homologous regions of CA17.67591, confirming that these strains belong to the same HEV-C serotype. High similarity scores were also observed when comparing the MAD04 and MAD29 cVDPV nt sequences encoding viral proteins 2B and 2C with those of CA17.67591, This was confirmed by comparing in a more detailed analysis nucleotide sequences — and to a lesser extent, amino-acid sequences — of genomic regions of CA17.67591, with those of other HEV-C (Table 1). Similar results were previously obtained from partial sequencing of CA17.67591 , suggesting that ancestors of CA17.67591 and other related CA17 isolates from Madagascar were the donor strains of some of the non-poliovirus sequences present in MAD04 and MAD29.
Figure 2. Comparative analysis of the genomic sequences of CA17.67591, cVDPVs and HEV-C prototype strains.
A) Similarity between the genomic sequences of CA17.67591 and other strains: prototype strains CA17-G12 and CA13-Flores, Madagascar cVDPVs MAD04 and MAD29, vaccine strain Sabin 2. The genetic organization of the PV genome is shown. B) Bootscanning plot of MAD04, MAD29, Sabin 2 and CA17 sequences versus CA17.67591 sequences (query sequence). Similarity and bootscanning analysis were performed with a sliding window of 400 nt, with a step of 20 nt (Simplot software version 3.5.1).doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.g002
Table 1. Sequences comparative analysis: CA17.67591 versus CA17-G12, Sabin 2, MAD04 and MAD29 strains.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.t001
Recombination possibility between these three strains was investigated with the bootscanning method  (Fig. 2B). These results confirmed that the MAD04 sequences encoding proteins 2B and 2C and the MAD29 2C and 3AB sequences are closely related to those of CA17.67591 and might have been acquired from a recent ancestor of this strain. In contrast, genomic regions encoding viral proteins 3C and 3Dpol (P3 region) and the 3′UTR of MAD04 and MAD29 did not show higher similarity with the homologous regions of CA17.67591 than those of the prototype HEV-C strains. These cVDPV sequences may originate from other Madagascar HEV-C strains. From previous results based on partial sequencing of the 3Dpol region, the cVDPV MAD04 and certain CA13 strains appeared to have a relatively recent common ancestor .
Molecular cloning of CA17.67591 infectious cDNA and construction of chimeric viruses
To confirm that CA17.67591 could be a recombination partner of PV and to determine main effects of this recombination event on the phenotype of recombinants, we cloned the infectious cDNA of this strain. Although the original isolate differs from the cDNA by a few nucleotides (mentioned in the chapter Materials and Methods), the cDNA-derived virus exhibited phenotypic characteristics similar to those of the original isolate as indicated below. We then used the cloned cDNA together with those of Sabin 2 and MAD04 to construct chimeric viruses (Fig. 3). The recombination site used for these constructs (nt position 3827, according to Sabin 2 nt numbering) was close to the natural site of recombination between mutated Sabin 2 and non-poliovirus sequences (nt 3801) found in MAD04.
Figure 3. Genomic structure of parental and chimeric viruses generated in vitro.
The genetic organization of the PV genome is shown (at the top). Closed triangles indicate natural or in vitro recombination sites.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.g003
The infectivity of the viral RNAs synthesized in vitro from the parental and chimeric cDNAs were tested in transfection experiments using HEp-2c cells. Infectivity ranged from 7.5 103 to 4.9 104 pfu/µg of transfected viral RNA, with recombinant cCA17/S2 RNA showing the lowest infectivity rate. These results showed that each RNA synthesized in vitro was able to produce viable viruses in HEp-2c cells, and that essential functions of the chimeric cDNAs were not impaired in comparison to their cDNA-derived parental viruses.
Phenotypic characteristics of chimeric viruses
Replication kinetic assays.
Replication kinetics of the chimeric cDNA-derived viruses were compared to those of the parental viruses in single-step growth curves (HEp-2c, 37°C). The cDNA-derived CA17 (cCA17) virus replicated as efficiently as the natural CA17.67591 isolate. The final viral yield was slightly lower for the cCA17/S2 virus than for cCA17 (Fig. 4A). However, the growth curves for cS2/CA17, cMAD04(2A)/CA17 and cMAD04(2A)/S2 were similar to those for viruses cS2 and cMAD04 (Fig. 4A and 4B). In HEp-2c cells, viruses bearing the 5′ half of the genomic sequence from CA17.67591 (cCA17 and cCA17/S2) had a lower capacity to replicate than viruses harboring 5′ sequence derived from Sabin 2 (cS2 or cMAD04). The 3′ half of either cS2 or cMAD04 could be replaced by that of cCA17 (in cS2/CA17 and cMAD04(2A)/CA17) without affecting viral replication.
Figure 4. Single-step growth curves of parental and chimeric viruses.
HEp-2c cells were infected with the indicated viruses, at a multiplicity of infection of 25 TCID50 per cell, and were incubated at 37.0°C (curves A and B) or 40.2°C (curves C). Viruses were harvested at various time points, and titrated. Standard errors of the mean of different samples are represented as error bars.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.g004
Viral plaque assay.
We investigated the capacity of chimeric and parental viruses to spread and form plaques in HEp-2c cell monolayers in a semi-solid medium (Fig. 5). Whereas CA17.65951 isolate and its cDNA-derived counterpart cCA17 formed very small plaques, cMAD04 formed very large plaques (Fig. 5A). The original Sabin 2 strain virus and cS2 formed plaques of an intermediate size. The chimeric cCA17/S2 formed very small plaques similar to those of cCA17, suggesting that the 5′ half of the cCA17 sequence determines the very small plaque size phenotype. Plaques formed by cS2/CA17 and cMAD04(2A)/S2 were of an intermediate size, between those formed by cS2 and cMAD04. cMAD04(2A)/CA17 produced plaques with a similar size to, or even slightly larger than those of cMAD04 (Fig. 5B). Taken together, these findings demonstrated that the 3′ half of the cCA17 genome modulates viral plaque size phenotype. In particular, the recombinant cS2/CA17 formed larger plaques than its parents cS2 and cA17.
Figure 5. Plaque size of chimeric and parental viruses.
Plaque assays were performed on HEp-2c cell monolayers infected with serially diluted viral stocks and incubated at 37°C for 72 h with semi-solid medium. Relative diameters were calculated, taking the average value of cMAD04 plaque diameters to be 100%. Relative plaque sizes (with standard deviations) of two experiments are indicated for viruses in series A and series B. The original Sabin 2 strain (S2) and the corresponding cDNA-derived virus (cS2) were used in series A.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.g005
As the original PV vaccine strains are temperature sensitive, we compared the replication kinetics of parental and chimeric strains in single-step growth curve experiments in HEp-2c cells at a supra-optimal temperature (40.2°C) (Fig. 4C). The capacity of viruses cCA17 and cCA17/S2 to replicate was lower at this temperature than at 37.0°C. Eight hours post-infection (plateau), titers were 1.3 to 2 log10 TCID50/ml (tissue-culture infectious dose 50 per ml) lower than at 37.0°C. Significant viral inactivation could be observed between 8 and 24 hours post-infection. Multiplication of cCA17/S2 was slightly slower than that of cCA17. cS2 also had lower titers at 40.2°C than at 37.0°C (plateau values reduced by 2 log10 TCID50/ml) and showed some inactivation between 8 and 24 hours post-infection. cS2/CA17 replicated more efficiently than cS2 and did not show a drop in titer after 8 hours post-infection. The cS2/CA17 growth curve showed some similarity to that of cMAD04(2A)/S2. The highest final yields were obtained with cMAD04 and cMAD04(2A)/CA17, which were fairly resistant to high temperature, with levels about 0.5 log10 TCID50/ml lower at 40.2°C than at 37.0°C, 24 hours post-infection.
The temperature sensitivity of viruses was also evaluated by titrating the same viral stock at 37°C and 40.2°C (Table 2). The original Sabin 2 (S2) strain, the CA17.67591 isolate and their cDNA-derived counterparts cS2, cCA17 and the recombinant cCA17/S2 were highly temperature sensitive; indeed, the titer was reduced by ≥3.6 log10 TCID50/ml at 40.2°C. The differences in titer for cMAD04, cMAD04(2A)/CA17 and the non-temperature sensitive environmental Sabin 2-derived S2 4568 isolate were ≤0.55 log10 TCID50/ml. cS2/CA17 and cMAD04(2A)/S2 exhibited intermediate differences in titer, of about 1.2 and 1.4 log10 TCID50/ml, respectively.
Table 2. Temperature sensitivity and pathogenicity of parental and chimeric viruses following IC inoculation.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.t002
These results showed that the 3′ half of the cCA17 genome renders the chimeric cS2/CA17 less temperature sensitive than the cS2, and makes the cMAD04(2A)/CA17 not temperature sensitive, like MAD04. Potential mutations in the cS2/CA17 viral stock were checked by sequencing at nt positions 481 (5′UTR) and VP1 codon 143. These positions are unstable in vaccinated individuals and are implicated in temperature sensitivity and attenuation , –; no unexpected mutations were found.
Neurovirulence of chimeric viruses
The pathogenicity of chimeric and parental viruses was evaluated in homozygous PVR-Tg21 mice that express the gene encoding the human poliovirus cellular receptor ,. Following the inoculation of pathogenic polioviruses through parenteral and intranasal (mucosal) routes, these animals developped symptoms similar to those observed in humans (paresis, acute flaccid paralysis or death). In this study, viruses were inoculated intracerebrally (IC) and intranasally (IN).
Viruses with the 5′ half genome from the original CA17 or S2 viruses — i.e. CA17.67591, cCA17, cCA17/S2, cS2, and cS2/CA17 — did not induce paralysis or death in mice at the highest doses inoculated IC (Table 2) or IN. Thus, they were weakly or not pathogenic in adult PVR-Tg21 mice. All other viruses with the 5′ half genome from the VDPVs MAD04, cMAD04, cMAD04(2A)/S2, cMAD04(2A)/CA17, and the highly neurovirulent environmental isolate S2 4568  were pathogenic following IC or IN inoculation.
To determine the dose that induces paralysis or death in 50% of mice (PD50), PVR-Tg21 mice were inoculated IC with serial dilutions of viral stocks (Table 2). The PD50 of cMAD04 and cMAD04(2A)/CA17 were similar (3.5 and 3.8 log10 TCID50) but lower than that of cMAD04(2A)/S2 (5.0 log10 TCID50). S2 4568 was the most pathogenic (PD50: 2.7 log10 TCID50).
A given dose of virus was also inoculated IN in PVR-Tg21 mice (Fig. 6). Mice inoculated with cMAD04(2A)/S2 were significantly less affected than those receiving cMAD04, cMAD04(2A)/CA17 and S2 4568 (Log Rank test: p<0.02). Pathogenicity of cMAD04(2A)/CA17 did not differ significantly from that of cMAD04 and S2 4568 (p>0.4).
Figure 6. Neurovirulence of viruses inoculated intranasally (IN) in transgenic PVR-Tg mice.
A given viral dose (106 TCID50 for neurovirulent viruses) was used to inoculate groups of PVR-Tg mice expressing the human poliovirus receptor (9 mice per virus). Animals were checked daily for paralysis and death, for 21 days post-inoculation. Healthy mice ratios following inoculation of parental or chimeric viruses or neurovirulent positive-control virus S2 4568 are shown. No symptoms were observed following the inoculation of the highest doses of cCA17 and cCA17/S2 (105 TCID50 per mouse) or cS2 and cS2/CA17 (107 TCID50 per mouse) – not shown for the last three viruses.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.g006
These data confirmed that MAD04 neurovirulence is primarily associated with the 5′ half of the genome of mutated Sabin 2 and that the 3′ half of the MAD04 genome modulates the degree of pathogenicity. These results also showed that the 3′ half of the genome from CA17.67591 can replace that from MAD04, rendering the recombinant cMAD04(2A)/CA17 almost as neurovirulent as MAD04.
Most cVDPVs reported so far were recombinants with unidentified non-poliovaccine enteroviruses — either wild PVs or non-PV HEV-C , –. Many of these cVDPVs were isolated in countries where wild polioviruses had disappeared, suggesting that these sequences were acquired by genetic recombination with non-PV HEV-C . The co-circulation of such recombinant cVDPVs with genetically related HEV-C Coxsackie A viruses was recently reported in Cambodia and Madagascar ,. Our studies showed for the first time that non-vaccine sequences present in a recombinant cVDPV can be replaced by homologous sequences of a co-circulating Coxsackie A virus. This provides further evidence that natural recombination occurs between OPV strains and non-PV HEV-C.
The characterization of the in vitro engineered MAD04(2A)/CA17 recombinant demonstrated that most of the P2 and P3 regions and the 3′UTR of the cVDPV MAD04 can be exchanged with those of CA17.67591 without significantly affecting phenotypic characteristics, such as viral multiplication in infected cells or pathogenicity in PVR-Tg mice. Additionally, changes in viral phenotype were observed when the 3′ half of the CA17.67591 genome was introduced into the vaccine Sabin 2 cDNA-derived strain cS2. The cS2/CA17 recombinant virus formed larger plaques in semi-solid medium and was much less temperature sensitive than cS2. Primary recombination events can therefore modify the phenotype of recombinants. Provided that the same differences hold true in the human gut, such a Sabin 2/CA17 recombinant could have advantages over Sabin 2 in nature, in terms of multiplication in the infected host, inter-human transmission or both. The viral population may be initially enriched for the newly formed recombinants.
Nevertheless, the cS2/CA17 recombinant was not neurovirulent in PVR-Tg21 mice. This confirmed that the mutated Sabin 2-derived 5′ half of the MAD04 genome, and in particular certain mutations in the 5′UTR ribosomal entry-site (nt 481) and in the VP1 genomic region (codon 143), are essential for pathogenicity ,. However, the fact that the recombinant MAD04/CA17 was more neurovirulent than MAD04/Sabin 2 suggests that the 3′ half of the CA17.67591 genome acts to promote neurovirulence. Alternatively, the 3′ half of the Sabin 2 genome, could interact with MAD04 to reduce neurovirulence. In any case, recombination between a slightly pathogenic vaccine PV mutant and a HEV-C strain may make the recombinant more pathogenic. In addition, recombination between an original vaccine PV and a HEV-C strain may favor viral multiplication, circulation and therefore genetic drift and acquisition of pathogenic characteristics. Regardless of the sequence of events leading to formation of pathogenic recombinants — whether mutations occur first then subsequent recombination or vice versa — recombination between vaccine PV and HEV-C may favor the emergence of cVDPVs.
The contribution of the 3′ half of the CA17 genome to phenotypic differences observed between PV/CA17 recombinants and PV strains remains unclear. Previous studies have shown that the P3-3′UTR region of PV, Coxsackievirus B3 and enterovirus 71 strains is implicated in pathogenicity in animal models and/or in temperature sensitivity of viruses –. It may also modulate diversity among quasispecies by affecting polymerase fidelity, as recently shown for type 1 PV . Recombination between PV and CA17 brings together different genomic fragments. Interactions between these genomic regions may then account for the specific features observed in these recombinants. The intrinsic properties of the 3′ half of CA17 genome and the encoded proteins, and their functional interactions with their PV counterparts, remain to be determined. This will help to elucidate the mechanisms by which recombination modifies the phenotype and gives rise to the emergence of recombinant cVDPVs.
The prototype HEV-C strains CA11, CA13, CA17 and CA20 are the most closely genetically related to PV ,. Viral isolates belonging to these four serotypes (characterized from VP1 nucleotide sequences) were found in Madagascar in the district of Tolagnaro where the four polio cases caused by MAD04 lineage cVDPVs were identified ,. The sequencing of the whole genome of one of the CA17 isolates (CA17.67591) which has a high sequence similarity to MAD04 in the 2C region, confirmed its genetic link with the MAD04 lineage and revealed that it is also related to the MAD29 lineage found in another district. We also identified genetic links between this CA17 isolate and the different recombinant cVDPVs lineages isolated in 2005 from other Madagascar districts  (Joffret et al. unpublished). CA17 strains, or at least viruses related to the CA17.67591 lineage, thus appear to belong to the common recombinant partners of PV in Madagascar. One study showed that the 2BC genomic region of a Sabin3/HEV-C recombinant from Cambodia was related to the 2BC region in indigenous CA17 strains . Given the extensive recombination rate that occurs naturally in all human enterovirus species ,,,,,,, we cannot exclude the possibility that other HEV-C strains or HEV-C/CA17 recombinants are actually the parents of the Madagascar cVDPVs. However, no such recombinants have been detected among the various HEV-C isolates having been collected in the Tolagnaro district . CA13 isolates from Tolagnaro were also found to be genetically related to MAD04 and MAD29. Recombination of PV with CA13 strains or with CA17/CA13 recombinant strains may be important for certain viral functions and for the emergence of cVDPVs. However, all the phenotypic characteristics of MAD04/CA17 were similar to those of MAD04. This suggests that sequences in the 3Dpol region of the cVDPV MAD04, which are related to those of certain co-circulating CA13 strains, do not confer additional selective advantages, at least in terms of the viral functions and characteristics studied.
Whether CA11, CA20 or some other HEV-C are involved in recombination with PV in humans remains unclear. The 2C sequences of a CA20 isolate from Tolagnaro were previously found to be related to those of MAD04 . A recent study of recombinants between the highly pathogenic PV strain Mahoney and a prototype HEV-C (CA20) suggested that the P2 or the P3 regions of the poliovirus genome can be exchanged with those of CA20 without any effect on viral multiplication and, in at least some cases, on pathogenicity in PVR-Tg mice . However, this study demonstrated that recombinants containing the capsid of CA20 (or CA21) and PV sequences are either dysfunctional or non-viable. Combinations of sequences and/or functions derived from PV and other HEV-C may therefore not be compatible and may limit recombinants variety. In this study, the chimera cCA17/S2 (with the 5′UTR and the capsid of CA17.67591) was viable, with multiplication and temperature sensitivity differing only slightly from cCA17. The CA20 - PV Mahoney pair appears to be less permissive for reciprocal genetic exchange than the CA17 – Sabin 2 pair. Unlike a CA20/type 1 PV Mahoney recombinant (with the CA20 capsid), the CA20/type 3 PV Leon counterpart was viable , suggesting that some viral factors (phylogenetic distance between viruses and/or functional determinants) may determine the viability and functional properties of recombinants. Nevertheless, small defects in viral function such as those found in CA17/S2 (compared to CA17) may result in selective disadvantages in humans. To the best of our knowledge, CA17/PV recombinants have not yet been isolated from humans.
In conclusion, this study shows that a CA17 isolate co-circulating with a PV/HEV-C recombinant cVDPV can be a recombination partner for PV. Recombination can have a beneficial primary effect on the key phenotypic characteristics of recombinants such as replication and may thus favor the emergence of pathogenic cVDPVs. PVs and CA17 have been recently classified as belonging to the same enterovirus species due to the similarity of their nucleotide sequences; however, these viruses differ greatly in terms of biological properties and pathogenicity in humans. PVs recognize CD155 as its viral receptor  and induce a severe paralytic disease. The binding of CA17 to cells seems to be mediated by ICAM1, similarly to the major group of rhinoviruses, agents of the common cold . Moreover, CA17 strains are thought to be poorly pathogenic or not pathogenic at all in humans . The co-circulation of these very different viruses in populations of children , and their evolution through intertypic genetic recombination may result in the appearance of more efficiently replicating variants enabling the emergence of new pathogenic lineages. This constitutes an interesting model of viral evolution and emergence.
Materials and Methods
Cells and Viruses
HEp-2c cells (derived from a human laryngeal carcinoma cell line) were grown as monolayers in DMEM(1×) high Glucose (with tricine, biotin) (PAA) supplemented with 1% of L-Glutamine 200 mM and 10% new born calf serum.
For the multiplication of viruses containing CA17-derived sequences HEp-2c cell monolayers were grown in DMEM medium containing tryptose phosphate broth and tricine (DMEM-TPB), supplemented with 1% of L-Glutamine 200 mM, 2% of sodium bicarbonate 7.5% and 3% fetal calf serum (FCS).
The coxsackie A virus CA17.67591 strain was isolated in 2002 and grown in HEp-2c cells from stools of healthy child living in the district of Tolagnaro, Madagascar .
The cVDPV strain MAD04 was isolated from stool specimens of a patient with poliomyelitis during the 2002 outbreak in Tolagnaro district ,. The corresponding cDNA-derived virus cMAD04 used in this study was previously described .
The poliovaccine virus Sabin 2 (S2) was obtained from the WHO [Behringwerke (S0+1)] “master seeds”. A second passage at 36°C in HEp-2c cells of the original seed was used to prepare viral stocks. The corresponding cDNA-derived cS2 was also used .
The PV strain S2/4568 is a non-temperature sensitive and highly neurovirulent Sabin 2 -derived strain isolated from sewage in Israel .
The CA17 prototype strain G12 (CA17-G12) was kindly supplied by the National Institute of Public Health and the Environment (RIVM), Bilthoven, The Netherlands and amplified on HEp-2c cells.
RT-PCR and sequencing
Oligonucleotides used for RT-PCR are presented in Table 3; most polioviruses- and enterovirus-specific primers were previously described ,,,. Viral RNA was extracted with QIAamp® Viral RNA Mini Kit (QIAGEN), according to the manufacturer's instructions. Reverse transcription was realised as described by Bessaud et al. , using the P1c primer. PCR was carried out in a final volume of 50 µl including 5 µl of Taq Buffer 10× with MgCl2, 200 µM of each dNTPs, 10 pmoles of each primers, 5 µl of cDNA and 2.5 U of Taq DNA polymerase (Taq CORE kit 10, Q-Biogen). The thermocycler profile was that of 20 sec at 94°C, followed by 40 cycles of 30 sec at 94°C, 30 sec at 45°C, 1 min at 72°C, and a final elongation step of 10 min at 72°C. PCR products were analysed on ethidium bromide stained agarose gels and purified with QIAquick PCR Purification kit (QIAGEN). The sequences of the resulting amplicons were determined using the BigDye terminator v3.1 kit (Applied Biosystems) and an ABI Prism 3140 automated sequencer (Applied Biosystems) using in most cases primers used for the PCR reaction.
Table 3. Oligonucleotides used for RT and PCR.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.t003
The 5′-end of the viral genome was amplified with the 5′/3′ RACEkit (Roche), as described in the manufacturer's protocol. Briefly, viral RNA was used for first-strand cDNA synthesis using the primer UC52; the cDNA was purified and a dA-tailing reaction was carried out. The dA-tailed cDNA was then amplified by PCR using the UC52 and oligo-dT primers.
Alignment of sequences and genetic analysis
Sequences were aligned and compared using CLC Combined Workbench 3.0 software (CLC bio, Aarhus, Denmark).
Phylogenetic relationships between sequences were inferred by the maximum likelihood method with PUZZLE 4.0, which uses QUARTET PUZZLING as the tree search algorithm . The Hasegawa, Kishino and Yano (HKY) model of substitution for nt with a Ts/Tv of 8.0 was used . Trees were constructed using neighbor-joining of PHYLIP (Phylogeny Inference Package) version 3.6  and branch length given by PUZZLE. The reliability of tree topology was estimated using 10,000 puzzle steps. Trees were drawn with NJ Plot .
Nucleotide sequences used for comparative and phylogenetic analysis were PV sequences of PV1-Mahoney, PV2-Lansing, PV3-Leon, Sabin1, Sabin2, Sabin3, MAD04, MAD07, MAD29 (GenBank accession numbers: V01149, M12197, K01392, AY184219, AY184220, AY184221, AM084223, AM084224, AM084225, respectively), nt sequences of prototype strains CA1-Tompkins, CA11-Belgium1, CA13-Flores, CA11v-G9, CA17-G12, CA13v-G13, CA19-NIH8663, CA20-IH35, CA21-Kuykendall, CA21(V)-Coe, CA22-Chulman, CA24v-EH24/70 (Genbank numbers: AF499635, AF499636, AF499637, AF499638, AF499639, AF499640, AF499641, AF499642, AF546702, D00538, AF499643, and D90457, respectively) and, finally, nt sequence of the prototype strain EV70-J670_71 belonging to the human enterovirus of species D (GenBank number: D00820), which was used as outgroup sequence. Former CA15 and CA18 are considered as antigenic variants of CA11 and CA13 , and are now named CA11v and CA13v, respectively
Similarity scanning (similarity plots) and bootscanning analysis , which depicted relationships among the aligned sequences, were generated using the Simplot software version 3.5.1 . Similarity and bootscanning analysis were performed with a sliding window of 400 nt and a step of 20 nt using Kimura 2 parameters and a transition/transversion ratio of 10. Bootscanning was performed using the neighbour-joining method. Bootscanning consists in the alignment of a possible recombinant sequence with putative parental reference sequences. Bootstrapped phylogenetic trees are built for each segment and finally the bootstrap value for placing the suspected recombinant sequence with the group of a putative parental sequence (CA17.67591 in this study) is plotted along the genome.
Prediction of viral RNA secondary structure was performed using a modified version of MFOLD available in CLC Combined Workbench software .
Construction of parental and chimeric cDNA-derived viruses
The molecular cloning of the Sabin 2 cDNA and the MAD04 cDNA in a modified pBR322 vector (pBR-S2 and pBR-MAD04, respectively) has been previously described .
Viral RNA isolated from the CA17.67591 viral stock was reverse transcribed and the cDNA was amplified using PCR as described above except that the Pfu Ultra II Fusion HS DNA polymerase (STRATAGENE) was used.
Two chimeric Sabin 2/CA17.67591 genomes (cS2/CA17 and cCA17/S2) were constructed. Plasmids, oligonucleotides and restriction sites used are given in Table 4. To get the cS2/CA17 cDNA (recombination site at nt 3827), a PCR fragment corresponding to the 3′ half of the CA17 cDNA was amplified with specific primers containing BseRI and NotI cloning restriction sites (Fig. 3) and used to replace the homologous fragment in pBR-S2. To construct cCA17/S2 cDNA, an AscI-BseRI restriction fragment amplified from CA17.67591 by RT-PCR was used to replace the homologous 5′ half of the Sabin 2 cDNA present in pBR-S2. The parental complete CA17 cDNA was reconstituted by replacing the Sabin 2 part of cCA17/S2 cDNA, by the 3′ half of the CA17 cDNA (BseRI-NotI fragment) present in the cloned cS2/CA17 cDNA. This CA17 fragment was also used to replace the Sabin 2 part of the previously described MAD04(2A)/S2 cDNA  to give the MAD04(2A)/CA17 cDNA.
Table 4. Initial plasmids, oligonucleotides, and restriction sites used for constructing viral infectious cDNAs.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1000412.t004
All constructs were verified by sequencing and CA17 cDNA sequences were compared to the original CA17.67591 viral stock. The original isolate differs from the cDNA by a few nucleotides (nucleotides 68 G->T, 89 A->T, 2053 U->C, 2401 U->C, 2730 C->T, 2794 G+A->A: Thr+Ala->Thr, 2997 G->A, 3819 U->G, 3825 A->T, 3834 A->G, 3840 C->T, 4302 A->G, 4809 C->T, 6906 C->T, 7339 C->T, respectively).
The T7 RNApol promoter localised upstream the cloned viral cDNA was used to transcribe infectious RNAs from linearized plasmid (T7 RiboMAX™, PROMEGA). DNA matrixes were eliminated by treatment with RQ1 RNase-Free DNase and viral RNA was purified by phenol/chloroform extraction or with the RNeasy mini kit (QIAGEN). HEp-2c cell monolayers were transfected with purified RNAs (Lipofectamine 2000, INVITROGEN) and incubated at 37°C, 5% CO2. Viral stocks were obtained following transfection of 9 µg of RNA/106 cells in DMEM-TPB supplemented with 3% FCS. After almost complete cytopathic effect, viruses were harvested and viral stocks were constituted following two subsequent passages in HEp-2c cells.
RNA Infectivity assay
The infectivity of the cDNA-derived viral RNAs was tested by transfecting different amounts of viral RNAs in HEp-2c cell monolayers that were subsequently maintained under a 1.2% Avicel (FMC Biopolymer) overlay . Six-well plastic plates were seeded with 2×106 HEp-2c cells per well in DMEM-TPB supplemented with 1% of L-Glutamine 200 mM, 2% of sodium bicarbonate 7.5% and 3% FCS and kept in an incubator at 37°C and 5% CO2 for about 24 h. Cell monolayers were washed twice with DMEM without serum, transfected using Lipofectamine 2000 with 1 µg of decimally diluted RNA per well and incubated at 37°C and 5% CO2 for 30 min. Then, the inoculum was removed and replaced by 2 ml per well of DMEM-TPB supplemented with 1% of L-Glutamine 200 mM, 2% of sodium bicarbonate 7.5% without serum before incubation at 37°C and 5% CO2 for 1 h. Next, the medium was removed and replaced by 3 ml of a mixture containing 1 volume of 2.4% Avicel in water and 1 volume of DMEM 2× supplemented with 2% L-glutamine 200 mM, 2% penicillin/streptomycin 100×, 4% tricine 1 M pH 7.4, 3% sodium bicarbonate 7.5%, 5% MgCl2 1 M and 4% FCS. Plaques were incubated at 37°C in a 5% CO2 incubator for 3 days. Avicel-containing medium was then removed; cells were washed twice with PBS (without CaCl2, MgCl2) and stained. The number of plaque forming unit (pfu) per µg of transfected RNA was calculated (mean of two experiments).
Viral plaque assay
Six-well plastic plates seeded with HEp-2c cells were prepared as described in the RNA infectivity assay. They were infected with 500 µl per well of decimally diluted viral stocks. Following washing, incubation under Avicel at 37°C for 3 days and staining, the diameter of all isolated plaques was measured and a mean plaque diameter and standard deviation (two experiments) were calculated.
Replication kinetic assay
Replication kinetics of parental and chimeric viruses were compared in single-step growth experiments. HEp-2c cells were infected at a multiplicity of infection of 25 TCID50 per cell. After adsorption for 30 min, cells were washed twice and incubated at 37.0°C in a 5% CO2 incubator or at 40.2°C in a water bath. Then, infected cells were frozen at various time points post-infection. Viral titers were determined for each time (TCID50/ml).
In addition to single-step growth at 40.2°C, the temperature sensitivity of viruses was also evaluated by titrating the same viral stock (TCID50/ml) at various temperatures in DMEM-TPB containing 2.2% FCS. One plate was incubated at 37.0°C (optimal temperature) in a 5% CO2 incubator and the second was incubated at 40.2°C (supra-optimal temperature) in a water bath. After 5 days of incubation, cells were stained and the titer (TCID50/ml) was calculated for each temperature. Results are expressed as the difference between the viral titre measured at 37.0°C and that at 40.2°C.
Assay of neurovirulence in PVR-Tg mice
Virus neurovirulence was tested in homozygous PVR-Tg21 mice that constitutively express the human poliovirus receptor CD155 (generous gift from A. Nomoto) . To determine PD50 groups of 6 six-week-old PVR-Tg21 mice (equal number of males and females) were inoculated IC with a given amount of each virus ranging from 103 to 107 TCID50/ml in DMEM containing 0.1% fetal calf serum (30 µl per mouse). Mice were examined daily for 21 days post-inoculation for paralysis and/or death and the PD50 was calculated by the method of Reed and Muench . Standard errors were determined according to the formula of Pizzi .
To evaluate neurovirulence a given dose of virus was also inoculated IN (2×5 µl per mouse) in groups of PVR-Tg21 mice (5 males and 4 females or 3 males and 3 females). Survival curves were determined according to the Kaplan-Meir method and compared using the Log Rank test with the XLSTAT software version 2008.6.05 (ADDINSOFT).
Viruses S2 4568 and cS2 were used as neurovirulent and non-pathogenic controls, respectively. To confirm the inoculated dose, viral inocula were back-titrated following inoculation.
All experiments were conducted in full compliance with French regulations regarding laboratory animal welfare. Protocols were approved by the Veterinary Staff of the Central Animal Facility of Institut Pasteur. Before IC and IN inoculation mice were anesthetized by intraperitoneal injection of 100 µl of PBS containing 0.25 µg of Xylazine (Rompun, BAYER) and 2.5 µg Ketamine (Imalgene, MERIAL).
Virus blocking assay
To test whether infection of HEp-2c cells by CA17.67591 was mediated by ICAM-1, we used a monoclonal antibody (mAb) against this molecule (clone 8.4 A6, Sigma) . A mAb against the PV receptor CD155 (mAb. 404, kind gift of Marc Lopez, Marseille) was used as control . Briefly, 2-days old confluent HEp-2c cells in 96-well plates were treated either by anti-ICAM-1, or anti-CD155 mAbs, or mock-treated for 2 h at 37° before infection, as described by Minor and coll. . Each well containing about 40,000 cells was then infected by 103 TCID50 of either CA17.67591, or Sabin 2 cDNA-derived strains, or mock-infected, in the presence of antibodies as described . Cell protection was evaluated under the microscope 4 days post-inoculation.
We would like to thank Dominique Rousset, Benoît Robert, Oumaima Granet, Marc Jouan and Bruno Blondel for encouragement and advice. We are also indebted to Jean Balanant for outstanding technical support. We are also grateful to the three anonymous reviewers for helpful comments.
Conceived and designed the experiments: FD. Performed the experiments: SJ MLJ CB FR CP IP MRA. Analyzed the data: SJ MLJ CB FR CP IP FCG MRA FD. Wrote the paper: SJ FCG FD. Investigated viral receptor usage: IP FCG.
- 1. Minor PD (1992) The molecular biology of poliovaccines. J Gen Virol 73 (Pt 12): 3065–3077.
- 2. WHO (2008) Progress towards interrupting wild poliovirus transmission worldwide, January 2007–April 2008. Wkly Epidemiol Rec 83: 170–177.
- 3. WHO (2008) Laboratory surveillance for wild and vaccine-derived polioviruses, January 2007–June 2008. Wkly Epidemiol Rec 83: 321–328.
- 4. Agol VI (2006) Molecular mechanisms of poliovirus variation and evolution. Curr Top Microbiol Immunol 299: 211–259.
- 5. Kew OM, Sutter RW, de Gourville EM, Dowdle WR, Pallansch MA (2005) Vaccine-derived polioviruses and the endgame strategy for global polio eradication. Annu Rev Microbiol 59: 587–635.
- 6. Adu F, Iber J, Bukbuk D, Gumede N, Yang SJ, et al. (2007) Isolation of recombinant type 2 vaccine-derived poliovirus (VDPV) from a Nigerian child. Virus Res 127: 17–25.
- 7. Estivariz CF, Watkins MA, Handoko D, Rusipah R, Deshpande J, et al. (2008) A Large Vaccine-Derived Poliovirus Outbreak on Madura Island-Indonesia, 2005. J Infect Dis 197: 347–354.
- 8. Kew O, Morris-Glasgow V, Landaverde M, Burns C, Shaw J, et al. (2002) Outbreak of poliomyelitis in Hispaniola associated with circulating type 1 vaccine-derived poliovirus. Science 296: 356–359.
- 9. Liang X, Zhang Y, Xu W, Wen N, Zuo S, et al. (2006) An outbreak of poliomyelitis caused by type 1 vaccine-derived poliovirus in China. J Infect Dis 194: 545–551.
- 10. Rakoto-Andrianarivelo M, Gumede N, Jegouic S, Balanant J, Andriamamonjy SN, et al. (2008) Reemergence of recombinant vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak in Madagascar. J Infect Dis 197: 1427–1435.
- 11. Rousset D, Rakoto-Andrianarivelo M, Razafindratsimandresy R, Randriamanalina B, Guillot S, et al. (2003) Recombinant vaccine-derived poliovirus in Madagascar. Emerg Infect Dis 9: 885–887.
- 12. Shimizu H, Thorley B, Paladin FJ, Brussen KA, Stambos V, et al. (2004) Circulation of type 1 vaccine-derived poliovirus in the Philippines in 2001. J Virol 78: 13512–13521.
- 13. Yang CF, Naguib T, Yang SJ, Nasr E, Jorba J, et al. (2003) Circulation of endemic type 2 vaccine-derived poliovirus in Egypt from 1983 to 1993. J Virol 77: 8366–8377.
- 14. Brown B, Oberste MS, Maher K, Pallansch MA (2003) Complete genomic sequencing shows that polioviruses and members of human enterovirus species C are closely related in the noncapsid coding region. J Virol 77: 8973–8984.
- 15. Pulli T, Koskimies P, Hyypia T (1995) Molecular comparison of coxsackie A virus serotypes. Virology 212: 30–38.
- 16. Stanway G, Brown F, Christian P, Hovi T, Hyypiä T, et al. (2005) Family Picornaviridae. In: Fauquet CM, Mayo MA, Maniloff J, Desselberger U, Ball LA, editors. Virus Taxonomy Eighth Report of the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses. London: Elsevier/Academic Press. pp. 757–778.
- 17. Racaniello V (2001) Picornaviridae: the viruses and their replication. In: Knipe DM, Howley PM, editors. Fields Virology fourth edition. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. pp. 685–722.
- 18. Hirst GK (1962) Genetic recombination with Newcastle disease virus, poliovirus and influenza. Cold Spring Harbor Symp Quant Biol 27: 303–308.
- 19. Ledinko N (1963) Genetic recombination with poliovirus type 1. Virology 20: 107–109.
- 20. Cuervo N, Guillot S, Romanenkova N, Combiescu M, Aubert-Combiescu A, et al. (2001) Genomic features of intertypic recombinant Sabin strains excreted by primary vaccinees. J Virol 75: 5740–5751.
- 21. Georgescu MM, Delpeyroux F, Tardy-Panit M, Balanant J, Combiescu M, et al. (1994) High diversity of poliovirus strains isolated from the central nervous system from patients with vaccine-associated paralytic poliomyelitis. J Virol 68: 8089–8101.
- 22. Guillot S, Caro V, Cuervo N, Korotkova E, Combiescu M, et al. (2000) Natural genetic exchanges between vaccine and wild poliovirus strains in humans. J Virol 74: 8434–8443.
- 23. Kew OM, Nottay BK, Hatch MH, Nakano JH, Obijeski JF (1981) Multiple genetic changes can occur in the oral poliovaccines upon replication in humans. J Gen Virol 56: 337–347.
- 24. Kirkegaard K, Baltimore D (1986) The mechanism of RNA recombination in poliovirus. Cell 47: 433–443.
- 25. Lindberg AM, Andersson P, Savolainen C, Mulders MN, Hovi T (2003) Evolution of the genome of Human enterovirus B: incongruence between phylogenies of the VP1 and 3CD regions indicates frequent recombination within the species. J Gen Virol 84: 1223–1235.
- 26. Lukashev AN, Lashkevich VA, Ivanova OE, Koroleva GA, Hinkkanen AE, et al. (2003) Recombination in circulating enteroviruses. J Virol 77: 10423–10431.
- 27. Rakoto-Andrianarivelo M, Guillot S, Iber J, Balanant J, Blondel B, et al. (2007) Co-Circulation and Evolution of Polioviruses and Species C Enteroviruses in a District of Madagascar. PLoS Pathog 3: e191. doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.0030191.
- 28. Simmonds P, Welch J (2006) Frequency and dynamics of recombination within different species of human enteroviruses. J Virol 80: 483–493.
- 29. Tolskaya EA, Romanova LA, Kolesnikova MS, Agol VI (1983) Intertypic recombination in poliovirus: genetic and biochemical studies. Virology 124: 121–132.
- 30. Lai MMC (1992) RNA Recombination in Animal and Plant Viruses. Microbiol Rev 56: 61–79.
- 31. Riquet FB, Blanchard C, Jegouic S, Balanant J, Guillot S, et al. (2008) Impact of exogenous sequences on the characteristics of an epidemic type 2 recombinant vaccine-derived poliovirus. J Virol 82: 8927–8932.
- 32. Oberste MS, Maher K, Kilpatrick DR, Pallansch MA (1999) Molecular evolution of the human enteroviruses: correlation of serotype with VP1 sequence and application to picornavirus classification. J Virol 73: 1941–1948.
- 33. Caro V, Guillot S, Delpeyroux F, Crainic R (2001) Molecular strategy for ‘serotyping’ of human enteroviruses. J Gen Virol 82: 79–91.
- 34. Oberste MS, Maher K, Flemister MR, Marchetti G, Kilpatrick DR, et al. (2000) Comparison of classic and molecular approaches for the identification of untypeable enteroviruses. J Clin Microbiol 38: 1170–1174.
- 35. Goodfellow I, Chaudhry Y, Richardson A, Meredith J, Almond JW, et al. (2000) Identification of a cis-acting replication element within the poliovirus coding region. J Virol 74: 4590–4600.
- 36. Paul AV, Rieder E, Kim DW, van Boom JH, Wimmer E (2000) Identification of an RNA hairpin in poliovirus RNA that serves as the primary template in the in vitro uridylylation of VPg. J Virol 74: 10359–10370.
- 37. Rieder E, Paul AV, Kim DW, van Boom JH, Wimmer E (2000) Genetic and biochemical studies of poliovirus cis-acting replication element cre in relation to VPg uridylylation. J Virol 74: 10371–10380.
- 38. Newcombe NG, Andersson P, Johansson ES, Au GG, Lindberg AM, et al. (2003) Cellular receptor interactions of C-cluster human group A coxsackieviruses. J Gen Virol 84: 3041–3050.
- 39. Shafren DR, Dorahy DJ, Ingham RA, Burns GF, Barry RD (1997) Coxsackievirus A21 binds to decay-accelerating factor but requires intercellular adhesion molecule 1 for cell entry. J Virol 71: 4736–4743.
- 40. Wellicome SM, Thornhill MH, Pitzalis C, Thomas DS, Lanchbury JS, et al. (1990) A monoclonal antibody that detects a novel antigen on endothelial cells that is induced by tumor necrosis factor, IL-1, or lipopolysaccharide. J Immunol 144: 2558–2565.
- 41. Lopez M, Aoubala M, Jordier F, Isnardon D, Gomez S, et al. (1998) The human poliovirus receptor related 2 protein is a new hematopoietic/endothelial homophilic adhesion molecule. Blood 92: 4602–4611.
- 42. Lole KS, Bollinger RC, Paranjape RS, Gadkari D, Kulkarni SS, et al. (1999) Full-length human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genomes from subtype C-infected seroconverters in India, with evidence of intersubtype recombination. J Virol 73: 152–160.
- 43. Salminen MO, Carr JK, Burke DS, McCutchan FE (1995) Identification of breakpoints in intergenotypic recombinants of HIV type 1 by bootscanning. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses 11: 1423–1425.
- 44. Cherkasova EA, Yakovenko ML, Rezapkin GV, Korotkova EA, Ivanova OE, et al. (2005) Spread of vaccine-derived poliovirus from a paralytic case in an immunodeficient child: an insight into the natural evolution of oral polio vaccine. J Virol 79: 1062–1070.
- 45. Macadam AJ, Pollard SR, Ferguson G, Dunn G, Skuce R, et al. (1991) The 5′ noncoding region of the type 2 poliovirus vaccine strain contains determinants of attenuation and temperature sensitivity. Virology 181: 451–458.
- 46. Macadam AJ, Pollard SR, Ferguson G, Skuce R, Wood D, et al. (1993) Genetic basis of attenuation of the Sabin type-2 vaccine strain of poliovirus in primates. Virology 192: 18–26.
- 47. Ren R, Moss EG, Racaniello VR (1991) Identification of two determinants that attenuate vaccine-related type 2 poliovirus. J Virol 65: 1377–1382.
- 48. Horie H, Koike S, Kurata T, Sato-Yoshida Y, Ise I, et al. (1994) Transgenic mice carrying the human poliovirus receptor: new animal models for study of poliovirus neurovirulence. J Virol 68: 681–688.
- 49. Nagata N, Iwasaki T, Ami Y, Sato Y, Hatano I, et al. (2004) A poliomyelitis model through mucosal infection in transgenic mice bearing human poliovirus receptor, TgPVR21. Virology 321: 87–100.
- 50. Shulman LM, Manor Y, Handsher R, Delpeyroux F, McDonough MJ, et al. (2000) Molecular and antigenic characterization of a highly evolved derivative of the type 2 oral poliovaccine strain isolated from sewage in Israel. J Clin Microbiol 38: 3729–3734.
- 51. Arita M, Shimizu H, Nagata N, Ami Y, Suzaki Y, et al. (2005) Temperature-sensitive mutants of enterovirus 71 show attenuation in cynomolgus monkeys. J Gen Virol 86: 1391–1401.
- 52. Georgescu MM, Tardy-Panit M, Guillot S, Crainic R, Delpeyroux F (1995) Mapping of mutations contributing to the temperature sensitivity of the Sabin 1 vaccine strain of poliovirus. J Virol 69: 5278–5286.
- 53. Merkle I, van Ooij MJ, van Kuppeveld FJ, Glaudemans DH, Galama JM, et al. (2002) Biological significance of a human enterovirus B-specific RNA element in the 3′ nontranslated region. J Virol 76: 9900–9909.
- 54. Tardy-Panit M, Blondel B, Martin A, Tekaia F, Horaud F, et al. (1993) A mutation in the RNA polymerase of poliovirus type 1 contributes to attenuation in mice. J Virol 67: 4630–4638.
- 55. Vignuzzi M, Stone JK, Arnold JJ, Cameron CE, Andino R (2006) Quasispecies diversity determines pathogenesis through cooperative interactions in a viral population. Nature 439: 344–348.
- 56. Arita M, Zhu SL, Yoshida H, Yoneyama T, Miyamura T, et al. (2005) A Sabin 3-derived poliovirus recombinant contained a sequence homologous with indigenous human enterovirus species C in the viral polymerase coding region. J Virol 79: 12650–12657.
- 57. Santti J, Hyypia T, Kinnunen L, Salminen M (1999) Evidence of recombination among enteroviruses. J Virol 73: 8741–8749.
- 58. Jiang P, Faase JA, Toyoda H, Paul A, Wimmer E, et al. (2007) Evidence for emergence of diverse polioviruses from C-cluster coxsackie A viruses and implications for global poliovirus eradication. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 9457–9462.
- 59. Mendelsohn CL, Wimmer E, Racaniello VR (1989) Cellular receptor for poliovirus: molecular cloning, nucleotide sequence, and expression of a new member of the immunoglobulin superfamily. Cell 56: 855–865.
- 60. Greve JM, Davis G, Meyer AM, Forte CP, Yost SC, et al. (1989) The major human rhinovirus receptor is ICAM-1. Cell 56: 839–847.
- 61. Melnick JL (1996) Enteroviruses : Polioviruses, Coxsackieviruses, Echoviruses, and Newer Enteroviruses. In: Fields DMK BN, Howley PM, Channock RM, Melnick JL, Monath TP, Roizman B, Straus SE, editors. Fields Virology, third edition. Philadelphia: Lippincott -Raven Publishers. pp. 655–712.
- 62. Chevaliez S, Szendroi A, Caro V, Balanant J, Guillot S, et al. (2004) Molecular comparison of echovirus 11 strains circulating in Europe during an epidemic of multisystem hemorrhagic disease of infants indicates that evolution generally occurs by recombination. Virology 325: 56–70.
- 63. Oprisan G, Combiescu M, Guillot S, Caro V, Combiescu A, et al. (2002) Natural genetic recombination between co-circulating heterotypic enteroviruses. J Gen Virol 83: 2193–2200.
- 64. Bessaud M, Jegouic S, Joffret ML, Barge C, Balanant J, et al. (2008) Characterization of the genome of human enteroviruses: design of generic primers for amplification and sequencing of different regions of the viral genome. J Virol Methods 149: 277–284.
- 65. Strimmer K, von Haeseler A (1996) Quartet Puzzling: A quartet Maximum-Likelihood Method for Reconstructing Tree Topologies. Mol Biol Evol 13: 964–969.
- 66. Hasegawa M, Kishino H, Yano T, Flemister MR, Pallansch MA (1985) Dating of the human-ape splitting by a molecular clock of mitochondrial DNA. J Mol Evol 22: 160–174.
- 67. Felsenstein J (2000) PHYLIP : phylogeny inference package, version 3.6a3 (computer program). Distributed by the author. Seattle: Department of Genetics, University of Washington.
- 68. Perriere G, Gouy M (1996) WWW-query: an on-line retrieval system for biological sequence banks. Biochimie 78: 364–369.
- 69. Zuker M, Mathews D, Turner D (1999) Algorithms and Thermodynamics for RNA Secondary Structure Prediction. In: Barciszewski J, Clark BFC, editors. A Practical Guide in RNA Biochemistry and Biotechnology. NATO ASI Series, Kluwer Academic Publishers.
- 70. Matrosovich M, Matrosovich T, Garten W, Klenk HD (2006) New low-viscosity overlay medium for viral plaque assays. Virol J 3: 63.
- 71. Reed LJ, Muench M (1938) A simple method for estimating fifty percent endpoints. Amer J Hyg 27: 493–497.
- 72. Pizzi M (1950) Sampling variation of the fifty percent end-point, determined by the Reed-Muench (Behrens) method. Hum Biol 22: 151–190.
- 73. Minor PD, Pipkin PA, Hockley D, Schild GC, Almond JW (1984) Monoclonal antibodies which block cellular receptors of poliovirus. Virus Res 1: 203–212.