Atypical/Nor98 scrapie was first identified in 1998 in Norway. It is now considered as a worldwide disease of small ruminants and currently represents a significant part of the detected transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE) cases in Europe. Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases were reported in ARR/ARR sheep, which are highly resistant to BSE and other small ruminants TSE agents. The biology and pathogenesis of the Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent in its natural host is still poorly understood. However, based on the absence of detectable abnormal PrP in peripheral tissues of affected individuals, human and animal exposure risk to this specific TSE agent has been considered low. In this study we demonstrate that infectivity can accumulate, even if no abnormal PrP is detectable, in lymphoid tissues, nerves, and muscles from natural and/or experimental Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases. Evidence is provided that, in comparison to other TSE agents, samples containing Atypical/Nor98 scrapie infectivity could remain PrPSc negative. This feature will impact detection of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases in the field, and highlights the need to review current evaluations of the disease prevalence and potential transmissibility. Finally, an estimate is made of the infectivity loads accumulating in peripheral tissues in both Atypical/Nor98 and classical scrapie cases that currently enter the food chain. The results obtained indicate that dietary exposure risk to small ruminants TSE agents may be higher than commonly believed.
Following the bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) crisis and the identification of its zoonotic properties, a sanitary policy has been implemented based on both eradication of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE) in food-producing animals and exclusion of known infectious materials from the food chain. Atypical/Nor98 scrapie is a prion disease of small ruminants identified worldwide. Currently it represents a significant part of the TSE cases detected in Europe. The restricted tissue distribution of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent in its natural host and the low detected prevalence of secondary cases in affected flocks meant that it is believed to be a poorly transmissible disease. This has led to the view that Atypical/Nor98 scrapie is a spontaneous disorder for which human and animal exposure risk remains low. In this study we demonstrate that in affected individuals, Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent can disseminate in lymphoid tissues, nerves, and muscles, challenging the idea that it is a brain-restricted infectious agent. Evidence for the deficiencies in the current methods applied for monitoring Atypical/Nor98 scrapie is provided that would indicate an underestimation in the prevalence in the general population and in the affected flocks. These elements challenge the hypothesis on the biology of this recently identified TSE agent.
Citation: Andréoletti O, Orge L, Benestad SL, Beringue V, Litaise C, et al. (2011) Atypical/Nor98 Scrapie Infectivity in Sheep Peripheral Tissues. PLoS Pathog 7(2): e1001285. doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285
Editor: David Westaway, University of Alberta, Canada
Received: June 21, 2010; Accepted: January 10, 2011; Published: February 10, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Andréoletti et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The different parts of this work were funded by (i) The Food Standard Agency (UK) M03058, (ii) the FP7 EU project 'Priority' (243950 FP7-KBBE KBBE-2009-1-2-06), and (iii) Programme opérationnel de Coopération territoriale Espagne - France - Andorre 2007-2013 EFA85/08-COTSA. Lymphoid tissue collection in Portuguese sheep was supported by AGROS 558 (PO AGRO 8.1). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE), or prion diseases, are fatal neurodegenerative disorders occurring in sheep (scrapie), cattle (bovine spongiform encephalopathy - BSE), or humans (Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease - CJD). The key event in TSE is the conversion of a normal cellular protein (PrPc) into an abnormal isoform (PrPSc) which accumulates in tissues from infected individuals . PrPSc is currently considered to be the only TSE biochemical marker. According to the prion concept, abnormal PrP would be the causative agent of TSE .
Following the BSE crisis and the identification of its zoonotic properties , , the control of human and animal exposure to TSE agents has become a priority. A sanitary policy has been implemented based on both eradication of TSE in food producing animals and exclusion of known infectious materials from the food chain.
In 1998 an Atypical/Nor98 Scrapie was identified in Norwegian sheep; the PrPSc signature was partially PK resistant and displayed a multi-band pattern as showed by Western Blot (WB) that contrasted with those normally observed in small ruminants TSE cases . After 2001 and the implementation of active TSE surveillance plans, a number of similar cases were identified in most EU members states as well in other countries, like Canada, USA and New Zealand . The transmissibility of Atypical/Nor98 agent has been demonstrated in both rodent models (transgenic animals expressing the ovine Prnp gene)  and sheep , .
Currently Atypical/Nor98 Scrapie represents a significant part of the TSE cases identified in the EU small ruminant population, where its prevalence was estimated to range between 5 to 8 positive small ruminants per 10,000 tested per year .
Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases have different biological features from those observed in other small ruminants TSE , . Sheep susceptibility to TSE is strongly controlled by polymorphisms on the gene (Prnp) encoding for PrP protein , . The homozygous and heterozygous ARR sheep are considered to be strongly resistant to both the classical scrapie ,  and the cattle BSE agents . This resistance has been the basis of a large scale genetic selection policy aiming at the control of TSE diseases by increasing the frequency of the ARR allele in general population and restocking affected flocks with ARR animals. In Atypical/Nor98 scrapie the sheep genetic susceptibility is significantly different from what is observed in classical TSE forms, with homozygous and heterozygous ARR allele carriers being susceptible to the disease , , , , .
Information about the tissue distribution of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent in the host species is limited , , ,  but research findings indicate that no detectable abnormal PrP has been found in peripheral tissues and that the infectious agent could be restricted to the central nervous system. This key feature led to consider that dietary exposure risk to Atypical/Nor98 scrapie is low. The apparent limited spreading of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie in the organism of affected individuals is also an argument supporting the hypothesis that this agent has restricted abilities to spread into the environment or between individuals. PrPSc detection generally correlates with the presence of infectivity ,  but infectivity has been reported in the absence of detectable PK resistant PrP . In this study, we investigate the potential presence of TSE infectivity in peripheral tissues (lymphoid organs, striated muscles and nerves) of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie from naturally and experimentally infected sheep. We then compared the relative infectivity level present in peripheral tissues with those estimated in similar tissues from classical scrapie affected sheep.
Atypical/Nor98 scrapie field cases (n = 7) collected in three different countries (Portugal, Norway and France) were investigated for the presence of PrPSc and infectivity in lymphoid tissues and central nervous system (Table 1). These sheep were of various Prnp genotypes including those associated with high susceptibility to Atypical/Nor98 scrapie (homozygous or heterozygous A136F141R154Q171– AHQ) or resistance (homozygous and heterozygous ARR) to classical scrapie or BSE , . Amongst the seven cases, five were identified by the active surveillance program either at rendering plant or slaughter house and two through the passive surveillance network (clinical suspects). Three of these cases were identified in fallen stock animals collected in three independent flocks where an Atypical/Nor98 scrapie case had previously been identified (Portugal).
Table 1. Abnormal PrP (PrPSc) and infectivity in central nervous system and lympho-reticular system of natural Atypical/Nor98 scrapie incubating or affected animals bearing various genotypes at codons 136, 141, 154 and 171 of the Prnp gene.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285.t001
In each of these natural Atypical/Nor98 cases, PrPSc accumulation could be detected in different brain areas by WB and/or Immunohistochemistry (IHC). Conversely, no abnormal PrP deposits were evidenced in any of the investigated lymphoid organs (Table 1).
Bioassay of brain homogenates prepared from these seven sheep into transgenic mice that over-express the VRQ allele of ovine PrP (tg338)  were positive for TSE. Surprisingly, despite the absence of detectable PrPSc, the lymphoid tissue homogenates from five out of the seven cases were positive for TSE in tg338 mice. The attack rate in mice challenged with lymphoid tissues was lower and the clinical onset was delayed compared to mice inoculated using CNS homogenate (Table 1). Brains collected in clinically affected mice inoculated either with lymphoid tissues or brain homogenates displayed a similar PrPSc WB pattern (Figure 1: lanes 5, 6, 7 – Figure S2), PrPSc deposits distribution and vacuolar lesion profile (Figure 2A, 2C, 2E- – Figure S2). All these features were identical to those previously reported in tg338 mice inoculated with a panel of Norwegian, French  and UK  Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolates. These phenotypic features were clearly different from those associated to two distinct classical scrapie isolates (Figure 1: lanes 1–4 and Figure 2B, 2F, 2H). Infectivity was demonstrated in lymphoid tissues from one out of the two investigated ARR/ARR Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases.
Figure 1. PrPSc Western Blot detection in sheep and tg338 mice inoculated with Atypical/Nor98 scrapie and classical scrapie tissues (10% tissue homogenate).
Lane 1: posterior brainstem from a Langlade classical scrapie affected sheep (case 10). Lane 2: brain from a tg338 mouse inoculated with striated muscle (semi-membranous) from the same sheep (case 10). Lane 3: posterior brainstem from a PG127 classical scrapie orally inoculated sheep (case 12). Lane 4: brain from a tg338 mouse inoculated with striated muscle (extra-ocular motor muscle) from the same PG127 classical scrapie affected sheep (case 12). Lane 5: cerebral cortex from an AFRQ/AFRQ Atypical/Nor98 scrapie natural case (case 1). Lane 6: AHQ/AHQ sheep (cerebellum-case 9) intra-cerebrally challenged with natural atypical scrapie (case 1). Lane 7 to 9: brain homogenates from tg338 mice inoculated with peripheral tissues from atypical scrapie cases. Lane 7: retropharyngeal lymph node (case 2). Lane 8: sciatic nerve (case 9). Lane 9: striated muscle (case 8). No PrPSc was observed in control tg338 mice inoculated with retropharyngeal LN from a negative control sheep (Lane 10).doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285.g001
Figure 2. PrPSc distribution pattern and lesion profile in tg338 mice inoculated with Atypical/Nor98 scrapie and classical scrapie sheep tissues.
(A–D) PET Blot (SHa31 antibody – NBT/BCIP black deposits- bar: 200 µm) of brain coronal section (thalamus level) from tg338 inoculated with (A) AHQ/AHQ atypical scrapie cerebellum (case 9), (B) posterior brainstem from VRQ/VRQ classical scrapie (PG127- case 12), (C) retropharyngeal lymph node from a ARR/ARR natural atypical case at preclinical stage of the disease (case 3), (D) striated muscle from a AFRQ/ARQ experimental atypical case (case 8) at clinical stage of the disease. (E–H) Lesion profile (vacuolar changes) in tg338 mice inoculated with: (E) Natural (case 3 - △) and experimental (case 9- ●) cerebral cortex from atypical scrapie cases, (F) Langlade (case 10-▽) and PG127 (case 12- ●) VRQ/VRQ posterior brainstem homogenates, (G) brachial nerve from an AFRQ/ARQ experimental atypical case (case 8-◆) and AFRQ/AFRQ natural atypical case (case 1-▽), (H) striated muscle from Langlade (case 10- ▽- semi-membranous) and PG127 (case 12- ●-psoas) classical scrapie affected sheep.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285.g002
Samples collected in two experimental Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases were also analyzed; these were from an AHQ/AHQ (case 9) and an AFRQ/ARQ (case 8) sheep which had been intra-cerebrally challenged with an AFRQ/AFRQ field Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolate (case 1, Figure 1: lane 5). These sheep had an incubation period of 964 and 2240 days respectively. In both animals' CNS, PrPSc displayed a WB banding pattern that was characteristic  of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie (Figure 1: lane 6 – Figure S2). In none of the investigated peripheral tissues PrPSc could be detected (Table 2). In the tg338 bioassay, infectivity was shown in some but not all tested lymphoid tissues, and in striated muscle and peripheral nerves from both cases (Table 2 – Figure 1: lanes 8–9 – Figure S2). Incubation periods were prolonged in comparison to brain homogenates and the attack rate was lower than 100%. The phenotypes of the propagated prions in tg338 mice (WB banding pattern, vacuolar lesion profile and PET Blot PrPSc distribution in brain) were identical to the one observed with natural Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolates (Figure 1: lanes 5, 7, 9- Figure 2C, 2E, 2G).
Table 2. PrPSc and infectivity in tissues from experimental (IC challenged) Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases and natural or experimental (oral or intra-cerebral challenge) classical scrapie cases.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285.t002
A similar experiment was performed using peripheral and CNS tissues from natural or experimental classical scrapie cases at clinical stage of the disease. This study involved two distinct classical scrapie agents (Langlade and PG127), which can be distinguished on the basis of their lesion profile in tg338 mice (Figure 2F). The inoculation of peripheral tissues homogenates from animals infected with those classical scrapie agents into tg338 resulted in a 100% attack rate transmission, but with prolonged incubation period by comparison to mice inoculated with CNS samples (Table 2). For both isolates, PrPSc WB banding pattern (Figure 1: lanes 1–4 – Figure S2), vacuolar lesion (Figure 3F, 3H – Figure S2) observed in mice inoculated with CNS and peripheral tissues were identical. As previously described and conversely to Atypical/Nor98 scrapie, PrPSc could be detected in the investigated lymphoid organs, and striated muscle , , ,  from all the four classical scrapie affected animals involved in this study (Table 2).
Figure 3. PrPSc detection limit of a Langlade classical scrapie isolate, a PG127 classical scrapie isolate and an Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolate.
Dilution series from (A, D) Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolate (case 9- cerebral cortex), (B) Langlade–case 10- posterior brainstem) and (C) PG127 (case 12- posterior brainstem) classical scrapie isolate, that were prepared in negative sheep brain homogenate. The tissue homogenates (see methods) are the same than the one used for endpoint titration in tg338 mice (Table 3). The samples were processed for PrPSc Western-blotting (A–C, TeSeE WB kit – BioRad, anti-PrP SHa31 antibody). After extraction (25 mg of brain equivalent material), the re-suspended pellet was either entirely loaded on lanes (A: all lanes – B and C: Lanes 4–6) or diluted in Laemmli's buffer before loading (B: lane 3, 1/50 – Lane 4, 1/10 – C: lane 3, 1/20). These dilutions were necessary to avoid a saturation of the signal. A classical scrapie control was included on the three gels to calibrate the signal (Lane 1). (D) The atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolate dilution serie (case 9: cerebral cortex) was tested using a commercially available rapid TSE test (TeSeE Sheep and Goat - BioRad) used for field TSE screening in small ruminants. Three different aliquots of each dilution were independently tested. The extractions were carried out. Results are presented as the mean +/− SD corrected optical density values. The cut off value (0.162 OD– dotted lines) was established as the mean of four negative control optical densities + 0.150 OD.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285.g003
In order to determine the cause of our incapacity to detect abnormal PrP in the peripheral tissues of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases that contain infectivity, classical scrapie (cases 10 and 12) and Atypical/Nor98 scrapie (cases 1, 8, 9) brain homogenates dilution series were prepared and processed for a OIE registered PrPSc detection WB (TeSeE WB Kit – BIORAD), a PrPSc ELISA detection assay (TeSeE Sheep and Goat - BIORAD) (Figure 3 and Figure S1) and bioassays in tg338 mice (Table 3).
Table 3. Classical scrapie and Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolates endpoint titration and infectious titre in ovine PrP transgenic mice (tg338).doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285.t003
According to the endpoint titration, the infectious titre in the Langlade and PG127 classical scrapie isolates were estimated to be respectively 106.8 ID50 IC tg338 per gram and 106.6 ID50 IC tg338 per gram (Table 3- Figure 4A). All the titrated Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases (n = 5, see Table 3) that we investigated displayed substantially higher infectious titres, ranging between 108.7 and 109.5 ID50 IC tg338/g (Table 3-Figure 4 B).
Figure 4. Infectivity titre in reference brain sample from classical and Atypical/Nor98 affected ewes.
(A–B) Intra-cerebral endpoint titration in a tg338 mouse model of CNS homogenate (20 µl per mice), (A) prepared from terminally scrapie affected sheep with Langlade isolate (12.5% homogenate - case 10 - ○) and with PG127 isolate (10% homogenate- case 13- △) – (B) an ARQ/ARQ (10% homogenate - case 14- ○) and an ARR/ARR (10% homogenate -case 15- △) atypical scrapie cases identified in field through active epidemiosurveillance program. Such titration allowed the determination of the infectious dose 50 (ID50) of the reference brain samples (Table 3). (D–E) Variation of the incubation period as a function of the infectious dose inoculated intra-cerebrally in tg338 mice. (C): Langlade isolate, (D): PG127 isolate and (E): atypical scrapie isolate. To establish these diagrams, the individual incubation periods and the number of ID50 inoculated in each mouse were plotted. The number of ID50 is obtained by multiplying the titre of the inoculum (ID50 IC in tg338 per gram of tissue) per the amount of tissue inoculated in each mice. On this basis, a four parameter logistic regression was computed (Sigma Plot) to provide a curve associating the incubation period and the number of ID50 inoculated with the observed incubation period.doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001285.g004
For the two classical scrapie isolates, WB detected PrPSc to a dilution of 103 (positive detection on 25 µg of brain equivalent material) which corresponded to 102.2 (Langlade isolate) and 102 (PG127 isolate) ID50 IC tg338 (Figure 3). For the AHQ/AHQ Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolate (case 9), PrPSc WB detection limit was the 1/80 dilution (312 µg of brain starting material) (Figure 3A) which corresponded to 106 IC ID50 in tg338 (Figure 4E). Similar results were obtained with the two other atypical scrapie isolates (cases 1 and 8) for which the detection limits of PrPSc assays were respectively equivalent to 105.6 and 105.5 ID50 IC tg338 (Table 3 and Figure S1). These results indicate that PrPSc detection assays currently used for field TSE testing could have a dramatically lower intrinsic sensitivity for identifying Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent than classical scrapie agent.
As previously described , , , , , , the end point infectivity titration data that was generated with the two different types of classical scrapie agents (case 10 and case 12) and the Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases (cases 14 and 15) were used to fit the best logistic regression models correlating the incubation periods in tg338 mice with the infectious dose (Figure 4). These models were then applied to estimate the infectious content in the different tissues using the incubation periods in tg338 mice (Tables 1 and 2).
By this approach, the infectious titre of three atypical scrapie samples (cases 1: cerebral cortex - case 8: cerebellum – case 9: cerebral cortex) were estimated respectively 108.7, 108.7, and 108.3 ID50 IC tg338/gram (Tables 1 and 2). The measured infectious titre in the same three samples, by endpoint titration in tg338, were respectively 109.1, 108.7 and 10 9.5 ID50 IC tg338/gram (Table 3).
In the investigated Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases, the infectious load in muscle and lymphoid tissues samples from sheep affected were close to the sensitivity of our bioassay (102,7 ID50 IC per gram of tissue); ie about 106 fold lower than the infectivity level measured (by endpoint titration) or estimated (on the basis of the incubation periods) in the same amount of brain prepared from clinically affected sheep (Tables 1 and 2).
In sheep affected by the two different classical scrapie agents the incubation period recorded in tg338 inoculated with lymphoid tissues and striated muscle were consistent with infectious titre about 10 fold lower than the one measured in brains from those terminally affected animals (Table 2).
Bioassay endpoint titration is considered as the most accurate method for determining the TSE infectivity titre in tissues. Although regarded as less accurate, dose-response relationships have been used as a method for infectivity estimation when endpoint titration data are not available; in such an approach, the incubation period observed in the inoculated mice is used to estimate the infectious titre of the samples tested , , , , , . In this study, the dose-response approach was used to estimate the infectious titre in various peripheral tissues from Atypical scrapie/Nor98 and classical scrapie affected sheep. For mice inoculated with peripheral tissue homogenates, the standard curve established using reference CNS homogenates was used, but it was established that the lesion profile was identical in the mice inoculated with the peripheral tissue and the CNS. Although it could be hypothesized that the nature of the peripheral tissue inoculated would impact on the observed incubation length in mice (matrix effect) and consequently on the estimated infectious titre, Dickinson et al. ,  demonstrated that in conventional mice the dose-response obtained with the spleen and the brain from ME7 infected mice are similar.
Together these elements indicate, that even if the peripheral tissues infectious titre reported are ‘estimates’, they provide a good guide to the relative infectivity levels that are present in the Atypical scrapie/Nor98 and classical scrapie cases' brain and peripheral tissues.
The presence of PrPSc and infectivity in small ruminant's peripheral tissues affected with natural classical scrapie or experimental BSE is well established , , , , . It is generally considered that peripheral tissues like lymphoid tissues and striated muscle contain much lower levels of prion than CNS from terminally affected animals. This concept is the basis of the statutory measures aiming at limiting the entry of small ruminants TSE agents into the food chain. Tissues considered to be the most infectious (named Specific Risk Material) are systematically discarded from consumption, but tissues that would potentially contain only a low level of infectivity might enter the food chain due to the feasibility/practicality of removing them.
In this study, the estimated infectivity level in skeletal muscle and lymphoid tissues from animals (n = 4) affected with two different classical scrapie isolates did reach up to 1/10 (weight/weight) of the infectivity found in the CNS from terminally affected sheep. These values are higher than those expected from previous work. This could be explained by the fact that previously available data on prion quantities in peripheral tissues of small ruminants (in particular those related to striated muscle) relied on biochemical measurement of PrPSc amount  and the cell types accumulating PrPSc and the composition of these tissues may have impact on the PrPSc recovery yield. Also, if in some classical scrapie cases a 3–4 log10 infectivity difference was reported between CNS and some lymphoid tissues using bioassay in conventional mice, in other classical scrapie cases, the same study reported that infectivity in lymphoid tissue was only 1 to 10 fold lower than in CNS .
The classical scrapie cases that were investigated in this work cannot be assumed to be representative of all field diversity as only four animal cases of highly susceptible genotypes were used. However, the results indicate that exposure risk to such TSE agents through the unrestricted entry in the food chain of potentially infectious tissues would be significantly higher than previously thought.
In most countries, the identification of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie was a consequence of the implementation of an active surveillance for TSE consisting in random testing for PrPSc presence in brainstem of a fraction of fallen or healthy culled small ruminants . In Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases, the sensitivity of PrPSc detection tests that are used for initial field screening or confirmation of TSE cases is debated. Several authors reported failure to detect PrPSc in some CNS areas like the obex area , ,  from known affected animals or discrepancies in results when applying different diagnostic tests to a same sample , .
The results obtained in this study by comparing the analytical sensitivity of biochemical PrPSc detection (using an OIE registered WB method and a validated rapid screening test for TSE detection, in small ruminants) and bioassay indicated that CNS samples that would contain up to 107.4.–107.7 ID50/g of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie (according to tg338 IC bioassay) could remain negative for PrPSc detection. In field, Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases (Table 1) PrPSc positive WB was observed in CNS samples in which infectious titre was estimated (on the basis of incubation period) to be higher than 105.8 ID50/g IC in tg338. Such discrepancies might reflect an individual variability of the PrPSc WB detection limits between atypical scrapie cases. It might alternatively be the consequence of a relative imprecision in estimating the titre of low infectious doses by the incubation period bioassay method.
In contrast to Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases, using two different classical agents the WB PrPSc detection sensitivity limit was about 102 ID50 IC in tg338 (ie a tissue with a titre of 103.7 ID50/g IC in tg338). These differences strongly support the contention that diagnostic assays based on PrPSc detection have lower performance for identifying Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases than classical scrapie cases. It is consequently highly probable that a significant number of Atypical/Nor98 cases remain undetected by field testing, leading to an underestimation of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie prevalence in the small ruminant population. It is however not possible on the sole basis of this study to evaluate the importance of such underestimation.
The under detection of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie in the field due to the sensitivity of the current PrPSc based approach would also impact on understanding of the biology of this TSE agent.
While under natural conditions, classical scrapie is known to transmit between individuals, the analysis of data collected through the active TSE surveillance program seemed to indicate that Atypical/Nor98 scrapie could be poorly or not transmissible at all. This is based on the lack of statistical difference of the observed Atypical/Nor98 frequencies between the general population and the flocks where a positive case had been identified , . The lower ability to detect Atypical Scrapie incubating animals using the PrPSc based methodologies means that this conclusion should be considered with caution.
Atypical/Nor98 cases are identified in older animals in comparison to classical scrapie , . The lack of PrPSc detection in peripheral tissues of reported cases suggested that Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent could be restricted to CNS. This is supportive of the hypothesis that Atypical/Nor98 scrapie could be a spontaneous disorder of PrP folding and metabolism occurring in aged animals without external cause , .
However, this hypothesis is questioned by the evidence reported here that a negative PrPSc testing result could be observed in animals harbouring high infectious titre in their brain and that the infectious agent can be present in peripheral tissues of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie incubating sheep. TSE are considered to be transmitted following oral exposure; initial uptake is followed by a peripheral replication phase which is generally associated with a dissemination of the agent in the lymphoid system and the deposition of large amounts of PrPSc. This peripheral replication phase is later followed by the entry of the infectious agent into the CNS through the autonomic nervous system , , , . However, in several situations, like BSE in cattle , ,  or classical scrapie in ARR heterozygote sheep , , the involvement of secondary lymphoid system is marginal, which does not preclude central neuro-invasion through the autonomic nervous system . It could be proposed that Atypical Scrapie/Nor98 might occur following oral exposure to a TSE agent, which would spread marginally in lymphoid tissues before neuro-invasion. The slow propagation of Atypical Scrapie/Nor98 in its host (long incubation period) and the impaired detection sensitivity level of PrPSc based assays would explain the apparent old age of detected cases.
The results presented here are insufficient to rule out the hypothesis of a spontaneous/non contagious disorder or to consider this alternative scenario as a plausible hypothesis. Indeed, the presence of Atypical scrapie/Nor98 infectivity in peripheral tissues could be alternatively due to the centripetal spreading of the agent from the CNS. However, our findings point out that further clarifications on Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent biology are needed before accepting that this TSE is a spontaneous and non contagious disorder of small ruminants. Assessing Atypical/Nor98 scrapie transmissibility through oral route in natural host and presence in placenta and in colostrum/milk (which are considered as major sources for TSE transmission between small ruminants) ,  will provide crucial data.
The presence of infectivity in peripheral tissues that enter the food chain clearly indicates that the risk of dietary exposure to Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cannot be disregarded. However, according to our observations, in comparison to the brain, the infectious titres in the peripheral tissues were five log10 lower in Atypical/Nor98 scrapie than in classical scrapie. Therefore, the reduction of the relative exposure risk following SRM removal (CNS, head, spleen and ileum) is probably significantly higher in Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases than in classical scrapie cases. However, considering the currently estimated prevalence of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie in healthy slaughtered EU population , it is probable that atypical scrapie infectivity enters in the food chain despite the prevention measures in force.
Finally, the capacity of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie agent (and more generally of small ruminants TSE agents) to cross species barrier that naturally limits the transmission risk is insufficiently documented. Recently, the transmission of an Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolate was reported into transgenic mice over-expressing the porcine PrP . Such results cannot directly be extrapolated to natural exposure conditions and natural hosts. However, they underline the urgent need for further investigations on the potential capacity of Atypical/Nor98 scrapie to propagate in other species than small ruminants.
All animal experiments were performed in compliance with our institutional and national guidelines, in accordance with the European Community Council Directive 86/609/EEC. The experimental protocols were approved by the INRA Toulouse/ENVT and by the Norwegian ethics committees.
Atypical/Nor98 and classical scrapie natural cases
The natural classical scrapie case (case 10) included in this experiment was a Romanov sheep born and bred in the Langlade flock where a natural scrapie epidemic has been occurring at a high incidence since 1993 .
Natural atypical scrapie cases were identified though active or passive surveillance programs in France, Norway and Portugal (Table 1). The Portuguese cases were identified in three independent flocks where an atypical case had already been identified in the past (additional cases). In all cases, PrP genotype was obtained by sequencing the Exon 3 of the Prnp gene as previously described . In each case, the polymorphisms at codons 136 (A/V), 154 (H/R) and 171 (R/Q), which have been demonstrated to strongly influence the susceptibility to TSE in sheep are indicated . Additionally the presence of a phenylalanine at codon 141 (F/L), which has been shown to impact on the susceptibility to atypical/Nor98 scrapie, was indicated , .
Atypical/Nor98 scrapie and classical scrapie experimental cases
Two sheep (one 12 months old AFRQ/ARQ (case 8) and one 14 months old AHQ/AHQ (case 9)) selected in a field flock were IC challenged with French AFRQ/AFRQ Atypical Scrapie (case 1) (Table 2). The animals were euthanized when showing clear clinical signs at respectively 2224 and 964 days post inoculation.
TSE-free Poll-Dorset sheep (VLA- Weybridge- UK) were used for intracerebral inoculation with Langlade isolate (case 10, inoculum derived from a VRQ/VRQ natural isolate), or PG127 isolate (inoculum derived from a VRQ/VRQ experimental case). Animals were killed when displaying evident clinical signs at respectively 380 days and 160 days post inoculation. Oral challenge was performed in 6–10 months old TSE-free New Zealand cheviot sheep. Animals were dosed with 5 g equivalent of brain material (1% brain homogenate in glucose) derived from an experimentally VRQ/VRQ affected sheep (PG127 isolate). Animals were culled at clinical stage of the disease (200 days post inoculation).
Tissue samples collection, homogenate preparation
All tissues were collected using disposable equipment (forceps and scalpels). The different field and experimental cases were sampled on different dates and/or places. Different instrument sets and containers were used for collecting, transporting and storing each sample. Finally, in all cases, peripheral tissues were collected before CNS to further reduce the risk of cross contamination. In natural Atypical/Nor98 cases, the nature of the tissues collected under TSE sterile conditions might have varied according to the country and date of collection. In all cases, CNS and at least one lymph node were available. In both Atypical/Nor98 and classical scrapie experimental cases, a large panel of tissues (including Central Nervous System, Peripheral Nervous System, digestive tract wall, muscle) was collected under TSE sterile conditions.
From the available samples, tissues homogenates (20% stock material) were prepared in Norway (Norwegian cases) or in France (French natural and experimental cases and Portuguese cases). The list of processed samples is given in Tables 1 and 2. In each case disposable equipment was used to manipulate the tissues. 20% tissues homogenates were prepared using single use grinding microtubes (Precess 48 - BioRad) and filtered through a 25 gauge needle (single use syringe). The tissue homogenates were then aliquoted (in 2 ml and 5 ml tubes) and stored at −80°C. Peripheral tissues homogenates and CNS homogenates were prepared separately.
Tissue processing and immunohistochemistry (IHC) detection
This method was performed as previously described . PrPSc IHC detection was first performed using 8G8 antibody raised against human recombinant PrP protein and specifically recognising the 95–108 amino acid sequence (SQWNKP) of the PrP protein.
For each sample a negative serum control was included, in which the primary antibody was either omitted or replaced by purified mouse IgG2a serum.
PrPSc Western-blot detection (WB)
An OIE registered Western blot kit (TeSeE Western Blot, BioRad) was used following the manufacturer's recommendations. For each sample, 250 µl of 10% brain homogenate were submitted to PrPSc extraction. The obtained pellet was denaturated in Laemmli's buffer (15 µl) before being loaded neat or diluted (Figure 4) on a 12% acrylamide gel, and submitted to electrophoresis and blotting. Immunodetection was performed using SHa31 which recognizes the 145–152 sequence of PrP (YEDRYYRE). Peroxidase activity was revealed using ECL substrate (Pierce) .
ELISA PrPSc detection
A commercially available TSE detection test (TeSeE Sheep and Goat - BioRad) was used according to manufacturer's recommendations. In summary, five hundred µL of the 20% homogenate were incubated for 10 min at 37°C with 500 µL of buffer A containing proteinase K. PrPsc was recovered as a pellet after addition of 500 µL of buffer B and centrifugation for 5 min at 20 000 g at room temperature. Supernatant was discarded and tubes dried. Finally, the pellet was denatured in buffer C (5 min at 100°C) and 1:6 diluted in R6 reagent before distribution into the wells , .
Paraffin-embedded tissue blot (PET blot)
PET blots were performed using a method previously described , . Immunodetection was carried out using SHa31 monoclonal antibody (4 µg/mL), followed by application of an alkaline phosphatase labeled secondary antibody (Dako reference D0314 – 1/500 diluted). Enzymatic activity was revealed using NBT/BCIP substrate chromogen.
Bioassay experiments were carried out in ovine VRQ PrP transgenic mice (tg338), which are considered to be highly efficient for the detection of sheep scrapie infectivity . At least six mice were intra-cerebrally inoculated with each sample (20 µL).
Prior to inoculation, homogenates were diluted (final concentration 10% or 12.5%) in 5% glucose sterile solution. Each homogenate was then tested for bacteria presence (blood gelose overnight 37°C culture) and non sterile homogenates were submitted to a heat treatment (60°C – 10 min). Heat treated samples are identified in Table 1. The impact of such heat treatment on atypical scrapie infectivity is currently unknown.
Portuguese and French cases' inoculations were carried out in UMR INRA ENVT 1225 (Toulouse, France) facilities while Norwegian cases were inoculated at the NVI (Oslo, Norway). Peripheral tissues and CNS homogenates were inoculated on different days in order to avoid any risk of cross contamination. In some cases, tissues autolysis resulted in the death of some animals inoculated which explain the low number of mice for some isolates. Mice were monitored daily until the occurrence clinical signs of TSE. Mice were culled when they started to show locomotor disorders and any impairment in their capacity to feed. CNS samples were individually collected. A part of the brain (cerebral cortex) was frozen for PrPSc Western blot testing (TeSeE WB kit- BioRad) and the other part of the brain was formalin fixed for vacuolar brain lesion profiling  and PrPSc PET-Blotting.
Reference Central Nervous System samples end point titration
Five different isolates were endpoint titrated in tg338 mice, by inoculating intra-cerebrally (20 µl) successive 1/10 dilutions of CNS homogenate in groups of tg338 mice (6 or 12 mice). The material used for the titration was 10% brain homogenate except for the Langlade isolate (12.5% homogenate).
Two classical scrapie inocula used for sheep inoculation (Langlade: case 10, posterior brain stem - PG127: case 12, posterior brain stem) were titrated in UMR INRA ENVT 1225. The titration of the Langlade material was already published in a previous study .
Two confirmed atypical scrapie isolates (one from an ARQ/ARQ Norwegian sheep: case 14, cerebellum and one from a French ARR/ARR sheep: case 15, cerebellum) were titrated in INRA Jouy-en-Josas. These isolates correspond to two atypical cases originally described in the Le Dur et al. study in which they were respectively identified as Lindos and DS8 .
Three additional atypical scrapie isolates (AFRQ/AFRQ: case 1, cerebral cortex- AHQ/AHQ: case 9, cerebral cortex– AFRQ/ARQ: case 8, cerebellum) were titrated in UMR INRA ENVT 1225.
The infectious titre (Infectious Dose 50) of the brain homogenates was determined by the Spearman-Kärber's method .
Estimation of infectious titre on the basis of incubation period
For each isolate, the incubation periods recorded in individual tg338 and the number of ID50 inoculated to each mice (number of ID50 per 20 µL of the inoculated homogenate) (derived from Table 3) were plotted on a graph. On the basis of this data a four parameter logistic regression function was computed (Sigmaplot). This function was then used to estimate the infectious titre (number of Infectious Dose 50) contained in tissue samples on the basis of the incubation period observed in tg338 mice , , , , , .
PrPSc versus bioassay analytical sensitivity
CNS homogenate dilutions series from three different Atypical/Nor98 scrapie cases (case 1: cerebral cortex – case 8: cerebellum – case 9: cerebral cortex) were prepared by successive dilutions in negative brain homogenate.
The prepared dilutions were: 1/2, 1/5, 1/10, 1/20, 1/40, 1/80, 1/100, 1/200, 1/400, 1/800, 10−3, 10−4, 10−5, 10−6, 10−7, 10−8. The dilutions series were tested for PrPSc using TeSeE Sheep and Goat ELISA test and the WB as previously described in the text.
The neat sample and 10−5 to 10−7 dilutions from the same series were inoculated in groups of 6 tg338 in order to assess the infectious titre (see paragraph: Reference Central Nervous System samples endpoint titration).
Dilutions series of CNS homogenates were prepared from the Langlade scrapie (case 10: posterior brainstem) and PG127 (case 12: posterior brainstem) homogenates that were endpoint titrated in tg338 mice (Table 3). For these dilutions an aliquot of the 20% stock homogenate (stored at −80°C) was used as starting material. The dilution series (neat, 10−1, 10−2, 10−3, 10−4, 10−5, 10−6, 10−7) were then tested by WB (TeSeE WB kit – BioRad).
PrPSc detection limit in Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolates. Dilution series from two atypical Atypical/Nor98 scrapie isolates (case 1: cerebral cortex, and case 8: cerebellum) were prepared in negative sheep brain homogenate. The tissue homogenates (see methods) are the same than those used for endpoint titration in tg338 mice (Table 3). (A–B) The samples were processed for PrPSc using an OIE registered Western-blotting technique (TeSeE WB kit – BioRad, anti-PrP Sha31 antibody). After extraction (25 mg of brain equivalent material) the re-suspended pellet was entirely loaded on gels. (A) case 1: cerebral cortex. (B) case 8: cerebellum. The same classical scrapie control than in Figure 3A-3C was included on the two gels to calibrate the signal (Lane 1). (C) The same dilution series were tested using a commercially available rapid TSE test (TeSeE Sheep and Goat - BioRad) used for field TSE screening in small ruminants. Three different aliquots of each dilution were independently tested. The extractions were carried out. Results are presented as the mean +/− SD corrected optical density values. The cut off value (0.162 OD– dotted line) was established as the mean of four negative control optical densities +0.150 OD. (○: case 1. △: Case 8).
(0.43 MB TIF)
PrPSc Western Blot profile and vacuolar lesion profile in tg338 mice inoculated with various tissues from an Atypical/Nor98 scrapie and classical scrapie affected sheep. (A) PrPSc Western Blot profile. Lane 1: posterior brainstem from a PG127 classical scrapie affected sheep (case 12). Lane 2: brain from a 700 days old negative control tg338 mouse. Lane 3: cerebral cortex from an AFRQ/AFRQ Atypical scrapie/Nor98 natural case (case 1). Lanes 4–7, brains from tg338 mice inoculated with various tissues homogenates prepared from an AFRQ/ARQ Atypical scrapie/Nor98 experimental case (case 8). Lane 4: cerebellum. Lane 5: prescapular lymph node. Lane 6: brachial nerve. Lane 7: external ocular motor muscle. Lane 8: brain from a tg338 mouse inoculated from a PG127 classical scrapie affected sheep (case 12). (B) PrPSc Western Blot profile. Lane 1: posterior brainstem from a PG127 classical scrapie isolate sheep (case 12). Lane 2: brain from a 700 days old negative control tg338 mouse. Lanes 3–9: brains from tg338 mice inoculated with various tissues homogenates prepared from two VRQ/VRQ PG127 classical scrapie cases (case 12 and 13). Lane 3: case 12, posterior brainstem. Lane 4: case 12, ileal lymph node. Lane 5: case 12, external ocular muscle. Lane 6: case 12, psoas muscle. Lane 7: case 13, posterior brainstem. Lane 8: case 13, tonsil. Lane 9: case 13, external ocular motor muscle. Lane 10: posterior brainstem from a PG127 classical scrapie sheep (case 12). (C–D) Lesion profile (vacuolar changes) in tg338 mice inoculated with homogenates prepared from different tissues (C) an experimental Atypical/Nor98 AFRQ/ARQ scrapie case (case 8) or (D) an experimental VRQ/VRQ PG127 classical scrapie experimental case (case 12). (C) ○ cerebellum ◆: brachial nerve, ▽: external ocular motor muscle. (D) ●: posterior brainstem, ▽: ileal lymph node, ○: external ocular motor muscle.
(0.53 MB TIF)
Conceived and designed the experiments: O. Andréoletti, L. Orge, S.L. Benestad, F. Schelcher, C. Lacroux. Performed the experiments: O. Andréoletti, L. Orge, S.L. Benestad, V. Beringue, C. Litase, S. Simon, A. Le Dur, H. Laude, S. Lugan, F. Corbière, P. Costes, N. Morel, C. Lacroux. Analyzed the data: O. Andréoletti, L. Orge, S.L. Benestad, V. Beringue, C. Litase, S. Simon, A. Le Dur, H. Laude, F. Schelcher, C. Lacroux. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: O. Andréoletti, L. Orge, S.L. Benestad, V. Beringue, S. Simon, H. Simmons, N. Morel, C. Lacroux. Wrote the paper: O. Andréoletti, L. Orge, S.L. Benestad, V. Beringue, S. Simon, H. Laude, H. Simmons, N. Morel, F. Schelcher, C. Lacroux.
- 1. McKinley MP, Bolton DC, Prusiner SB (1983) A protease-resistant protein is a structural component of the scrapie prion. Cell 35: 57–62.
- 2. Prusiner SB (1982) Novel proteinaceous infectious particles cause scrapie. Science 216: 136–144.
- 3. Collinge J, Sidle KC, Meads J, Ironside J, Hill AF (1996) Molecular analysis of prion strain variation and the aetiology of ‘new variant’ CJD. Nature 383: 685–690.
- 4. Bruce ME, Will RG, Ironside JW, McConnell I, Drummond D, et al. (1997) Transmissions to mice indicate that ‘new variant’ CJD is caused by the BSE agent. Nature 389: 498–501.
- 5. Benestad SL, Sarradin P, Thu B, Schonheit J, Tranulis MA, et al. (2003) Cases of scrapie with unusual features in Norway and designation of a new type, Nor98. Vet Rec 153: 202–208.
- 6. Benestad SL, Arsac JN, Goldmann W, Noremark M (2008) Atypical/Nor98 scrapie: properties of the agent, genetics, and epidemiology. Vet Res 39: 19.
- 7. Le Dur A, Beringue V, Andreoletti O, Reine F, Lai TL, et al. (2005) A newly identified type of scrapie agent can naturally infect sheep with resistant PrP genotypes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 16031–16036.
- 8. Simmons MM, Konold T, Simmons HA, Spencer YI, Lockey R, et al. (2007) Experimental transmission of atypical scrapie to sheep. BMC Vet Res 3: 20.
- 9. Simmons MM, Konold T, Thurston L, Bellworthy SJ, Chaplin MJ, et al. (2010) The natural atypical scrapie phenotype is preserved on experimental transmission and sub-passage in PRNP homologous sheep. BMC Vet Res 6: 14.
- 10. Fediaevsky A, Tongue SC, Noremark M, Calavas D, Ru G, et al. (2008) A descriptive study of the prevalence of atypical and classical scrapie in sheep in 20 European countries. BMC Vet Res 4: 19.
- 11. Elsen JM, Amigues Y, Schelcher F, Ducrocq V, Andreoletti O, et al. (1999) Genetic susceptibility and transmission factors in scrapie: detailed analysis of an epidemic in a closed flock of Romanov. Arch Virol 144: 431–445.
- 12. Hunter N, Goldmann W, Foster JD, Cairns D, Smith G (1997) Natural scrapie and PrP genotype: case-control studies in British sheep. Vet Rec 141: 137–140.
- 13. Jeffrey M, Martin S, Thomson JR, Dingwall WS, Begara-McGorum I, et al. (2001) Onset and distribution of tissue prp accumulation in scrapie-affected suffolk sheep as demonstrated by sequential necropsies and tonsillar biopsies. J Comp Pathol 125: 48–57.
- 14. Arsac JN, Andreoletti O, Bilheude JM, Lacroux C, Benestad SL, et al. (2007) Similar biochemical signatures and prion protein genotypes in atypical scrapie and Nor98 cases, France and Norway. Emerg Infect Dis 13: 58–65.
- 15. Moreno CR, Moazami-Goudarzi K, Laurent P, Cazeau G, Andreoletti O, et al. (2007) Which PrP haplotypes in a French sheep population are the most susceptible to atypical scrapie? Arch Virol 152: 1229–1232.
- 16. Saunders GC, Cawthraw S, Mountjoy SJ, Hope J, Windl O (2006) PrP genotypes of atypical scrapie cases in Great Britain. J Gen Virol 87: 3141–3149.
- 17. Luhken G, Buschmann A, Brandt H, Eiden M, Groschup MH, et al. (2007) Epidemiological and genetical differences between classical and atypical scrapie cases. Vet Res 38: 65–80.
- 18. Luhken G, Buschmann A, Groschup MH, Erhardt G (2004) Prion protein allele A136 H154Q171 is associated with high susceptibility to scrapie in purebred and crossbred German Merinoland sheep. Arch Virol 149: 1571–1580.
- 19. Buschmann A, Luhken G, Schultz J, Erhardt G, Groschup MH (2004) Neuronal accumulation of abnormal prion protein in sheep carrying a scrapie-resistant genotype (PrPARR/ARR). J Gen Virol 85: 2727–2733.
- 20. Nentwig A, Oevermann A, Heim D, Botteron C, Zellweger K, et al. (2007) Diversity in neuroanatomical distribution of abnormal prion protein in atypical scrapie. PLoS Pathog 3: e82.
- 21. Vidal E, Tortosa R, Costa C, Benavides J, Francino O, et al. (2008) Lack of PrP(sc) immunostaining in intracranial ectopic lymphoid follicles in a sheep with concomitant non-suppurative encephalitis and Nor98-like atypical scrapie: a case report. Vet J 177: 283–288.
- 22. Race R, Raines A, Raymond GJ, Caughey B, Chesebro B (2001) Long-term subclinical carrier state precedes scrapie replication and adaptation in a resistant species: analogies to bovine spongiform encephalopathy and variant creutzfeldt-jakob disease in humans. J Virol 75: 10106–10112.
- 23. Lasmezas CI, Deslys JP, Robain O, Jaegly A, Beringue V, et al. (1997) Transmission of the BSE agent to mice in the absence of detectable abnormal prion protein. Science 275: 402–405.
- 24. Griffiths PC, Spiropoulos J, Lockey R, Tout AC, Jayasena D, et al. (2010) Characterisation of atypical scrapie cases from Great Britain in transgenic ovine PrP mice. J Gen Virol 91: 2132–8.
- 25. Andreoletti O, Berthon P, Marc D, Sarradin P, Grosclaude J, et al. (2000) Early accumulation of PrP(Sc) in gut-associated lymphoid and nervous tissues of susceptible sheep from a Romanov flock with natural scrapie. J Gen Virol 81 Pt 12: 3115–3126.
- 26. Andreoletti O, Simon S, Lacroux C, Morel N, Tabouret G, et al. (2004) PrPSc accumulation in myocytes from sheep incubating natural scrapie. Nat Med 10: 591–593.
- 27. Hadlow WJ, Kennedy RC, Race RE (1982) Natural infection of Suffolk sheep with scrapie virus. J Infect Dis 146: 657–664.
- 28. Lacroux C, Corbiere F, Tabouret G, Lugan S, Costes P, et al. (2007) Dynamics and genetics of PrPSc placental accumulation in sheep. J Gen Virol 88: 1056–1061.
- 29. Dickinson AG, Fraser H (1969) Genetical control of the concentration of ME7 scrapie agent in mouse spleen. J Comp Pathol 79: 363–366.
- 30. Dickinson AG, Meikle VM, Fraser H (1969) Genetical control of the concentration of ME7 scrapie agent in the brain of mice. J Comp Pathol 79: 15–22.
- 31. Prusiner SB, Cochran SP, Groth DF, Downey DE, Bowman KA, et al. (1982) Measurement of the scrapie agent using an incubation time interval assay. Ann Neurol 11: 353–358.
- 32. Lacroux C, Simon S, Benestad SL, Maillet S, Mathey J, et al. (2008) Prions in milk from ewes incubating natural scrapie. PLoS Pathog 4: e1000238.
- 33. Heikenwalder M, Federau C, Boehmer L, Schwarz P, Wagner M, et al. (2007) Germinal center B cells are dispensable in prion transport and neuroinvasion. J Neuroimmunol 192: 113–123.
- 34. Tixador P, Herzog L, Reine F, Jaumain E, Chapuis J, et al. (2010) The physical relationship between infectivity and prion protein aggregates is strain-dependent. PLoS Pathog 15 6(4): e1000859.
- 35. van Keulen LJ, Schreuder BE, Vromans ME, Langeveld JP, Smits MA (2000) Pathogenesis of natural scrapie in sheep. Arch Virol Suppl 16: 57–71.
- 36. van Keulen LJ, Vromans ME, Dolstra CH, Bossers A, van Zijderveld FG (2008) Pathogenesis of bovine spongiform encephalopathy in sheep. Arch Virol 153: 445–453.
- 37. van Keulen LJ, Vromans ME, van Zijderveld FG (2002) Early and late pathogenesis of natural scrapie infection in sheep. Apmis 110: 23–32.
- 38. Fediaevsky A, Maurella C, Noremark M, Ingravalle F, Thorgeirsdottir S, et al. (2010) The prevalence of atypical scrapie in sheep from positive flocks is not higher than in the general sheep population in 11 European countries. BMC Vet Res 6: 9.
- 39. Fediaevsky A, Morignat E, Ducrot C, Calavas D (2009) A case-control study on the origin of atypical scrapie in sheep, France. Emerg Infect Dis 15: 710–718.
- 40. Buschmann A, Groschup MH (2005) TSE eradication in small ruminants—quo vadis? Berl Munch Tierarztl Wochenschr 118: 365–371.
- 41. Wells GA, Spiropoulos J, Hawkins SA, Ryder SJ (2005) Pathogenesis of experimental bovine spongiform encephalopathy: preclinical infectivity in tonsil and observations on the distribution of lingual tonsil in slaughtered cattle. Vet Rec 156: 401–407.
- 42. Wells GA (2003) Pathogenesis of BSE. Vet Res Commun 27: Suppl 125–28.
- 43. Terry LA, Marsh S, Ryder SJ, Hawkins SA, Wells GA, et al. (2003) Detection of disease-specific PrP in the distal ileum of cattle exposed orally to the agent of bovine spongiform encephalopathy. Vet Rec 152: 387–392.
- 44. Andreoletti O, Berthon P, Levavasseur E, Marc D, Lantier F, et al. (2002) Phenotyping of protein-prion (PrPsc)-accumulating cells in lymphoid and neural tissues of naturally scrapie-affected sheep by double-labeling immunohistochemistry. J Histochem Cytochem 50: 1357–1370.
- 45. van Keulen LJ, Schreuder BE, Meloen RH, Mooij-Harkes G, Vromans ME, et al. (1996) Immunohistochemical detection of prion protein in lymphoid tissues of sheep with natural scrapie. J Clin Microbiol 34: 1228–1231.
- 46. Hoffmann C, Ziegler U, Buschmann A, Weber A, Kupfer L, et al. (2007) Prions spread via the autonomic nervous system from the gut to the central nervous system in cattle incubating bovine spongiform encephalopathy. J Gen Virol 88: 1048–1055.
- 47. Espinosa JC, Herva ME, Andreoletti O, Padilla D, Lacroux C, et al. (2009) Transgenic mice expressing porcine prion protein resistant to classical scrapie but susceptible to sheep bovine spongiform encephalopathy and atypical scrapie. Emerg Infect Dis 15: 1214–1221.
- 48. Hunter N, Foster JD, Goldmann W, Stear MJ, Hope J, et al. (1996) Natural scrapie in a closed flock of Cheviot sheep occurs only in specific PrP genotypes. Arch Virol 141: 809–824.
- 49. Moum T, Olsaker I, Hopp P, Moldal T, Valheim M, et al. (2005) Polymorphisms at codons 141 and 154 in the ovine prion protein gene are associated with scrapie Nor98 cases. J Gen Virol 86: 231–235.
- 50. Andreoletti O, Berthon P, Levavasseur E, Marc D, Lantier F, et al. (2002) Phenotyping of Protein-Prion (PrPsc)-accumulating Cells in Lymphoid and Neural Tissues of Naturally Scrapie-affected Sheep by Double-labeling Immunohistochemistry. J Histochem Cytochem 50: 1357–1370.
- 51. Tabouret G, Lacroux C, Lugan S, Corbiere F, Weisbecker JL, et al. (2010) Relevancy of oral experimental challenge with classical scrapie in sheep. J Gen Virol 91: 2139–44.
- 52. Schulz-Schaeffer WJ, Tschoke S, Kranefuss N, Drose W, Hause-Reitner D, et al. (2000) The paraffin-embedded tissue blot detects PrP(Sc) early in the incubation time in prion diseases. Am J Pathol 156: 51–56.
- 53. Wemheuer WM, Benestad SL, Wrede A, Schulze-Sturm U, Wemheuer WE, et al. (2009) Similarities between forms of sheep scrapie and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease are encoded by distinct prion types. Am J Pathol 175: 2566–2573.
- 54. Vilotte JL, Soulier S, Essalmani R, Stinnakre MG, Vaiman D, et al. (2001) Markedly increased susceptibility to natural sheep scrapie of transgenic mice expressing ovine prp. J Virol 75: 5977–5984.
- 55. Fraser H, Dickinson AG (1968) The sequential development of the brain lesion of scrapie in three strains of mice. J Comp Pathol 78: 301–311.
- 56. Markus RA, Frank J, Groshen S, Azen SP (1995) An alternative approach to the optimal design of an LD50 bioassay. Stat Med 14: 841–852.